Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout2011-07-05 Board of Selectmen Handout' i READING ICI E . s; 15-Union- Street - Reading, Massachusetts 01867 - - - - - - - Emergency Only: 911 - All Other Calls: (781) 944-1212 - Fax: (781) 944-2893 www.ci.reading.ma.us/police/ TUESDAY JULY 5, 2011 BOS/LIQUOR LICENSING AUTHORITY HEARINGS ON VIOLATIONS OF MGL 038 s34 SALE.OR DELIVERY OF AN ALCHOHOL BEVERAGE TO A PERSON LESS THAN TWENTY-ONE YEARS OF AGE PACKET CONTENTS 1-Article from 3/17/2011 Reading Daily Times Chronicle announcing Reading Police Dept's 2011 alcohol enforcement efforts. (2 pages) 2- Article from 3/14/2011 ReadingPatch announcing Reading Police Dept's 2011 underage drinking crackdown. (2 pages) 3-Reading Police Dept's alcohol related. activities prior to underage operative stings (1 page) 4-Training rosters from RCASA Director for the TIPS program (2 pages) 5-Reports from the Underage Operative Stings for: Wednesday June 22, 2011 Thursday June 23, 2011 Friday` June 24, 2011 6-Photos of underage operatives 7-Liquor Compliance Check Guidelines (2 pages) 8-Chief Cormier's request to BOS for hearing on violations. tl H D" Nwfar6 17, 2011 f f, f rt F / oil . t A-4L ti. rmv"i'tvx5 Alt a " r zc u £ FLR f' 1870 Serving Burlington, Reading, , ~ x} 14` t E! ta.eficld, A'inche tc rWohurn 6- - 31 Police t. target unde-raggt 1co ol, ab se 011 enf i cement efforts include park patrols R1 ADI `G - The Y,eading' Poli ce Department is targeting underage alcohol abuse. in -'oll using a variety of enforcement . tactics: - According to a release from ! Beading Police Chief James Cormier, these operations include Cops in Shops, underage stings or aiinphance checks, party patrols, and surveillance i patrols. _ An overview of each tvpe of !operation is described below' . Cops in Shops" =tiffs opera _ tion typically consists of one unde_niover officer who works inside the store while a second officer is positioned outside the establishment to apprehend adults that procure alcohol for youths. Cops in Shops places the focus on the perpetrators minors that Gy to purchase alc 6 .,U llegally and adults that tb- t.o.purchase alcohol r~iillleeggaglll y,for minors Signs are placed u U-livmakers hear lesthno-iny. on parole cha es Reading's Chuck Maguire par~c'<pates Ili, AP and Cloff ~ r tlriduy but tile warm «~atlier ? ~1.ias pi ilroriic'L, pt£orographer Bill Ryiersora pat eo : and pussy'Aillows showing bud on Jo-1- the Old Sou`.h United Methodist Church' in n-ow will tDn Out m the 6N- - _ Atf.a~..iiV.Vi 11;GJ 11•.2L; R[L).1L41 t:~..LGl1 ~J• , - ofi by BILL ET0S 'W- and per- 'Students manned the sound forme l 4va small' cast those board . (ALEXAI llRA PO`P C €ntinu6d frora.Wage A! infunacy could be .felt on anti. KEN, AIAT"P Il4ETZGER). I muntty to gather information off st ty inside and outside of ~orlced the lights(A;LEY Stores prior to the operation to on potential.underage drin_" the rforriiarfces all three of CC7RAY L£ZZY'Ot7ii.DlilJ) ant otif patrons of the possible pnolations, the pdrforinances! . So what, do made sure that headsets aric presence of `undercover offi These locations may r mean by aIl three pe.-for~n , cro, ones were working anc tiers. include local sparting events, ances. T :farce captured a in place (TOTYWY. BISHOP Underage stings/compli town eor servation larid, :park- discombobulated.'. troop : of AASHI JHOTA, JAME: as - checks Underage young izg aieas, and other. as acirrs' trvzng4' put oii a play, 11~1C`F`ARLA.NE, AVERY ST R. 0 adults t rider the direction: of identified as "hot spots but they couldn't get ;their play NiA~I)• Props were not, lost Reading Police wi11'corne.nto Potential cruniial offenses right of ther.hfe deindI on even the: :sardines! TlkarTls t.c kocal businesses dtirng the that maybe idaRtified clurin it_ Each actor and actress Iiad COURTLY I1D50I~T, -LINID dear, to try to :buy alcoholic: party.. Patrols may. include but a spe ijuc relationshjp- Fyitli the 8EY lk l DOVE and::ttieii beverages. Poli ce officers tiaiIl are not limited to protective oLliers off-std tht`~as differ- crew .,'With the glarnrtl .i }idol ! k e working witn these youtlts. custctiiy} frunor in possr scion tint fro!n their relationship on- ~riappenLng on stage, one car ; usinesses where sales to open caritainer, ;itrivirig under stagy but as their play and of ly ni rvA at the great `jilt pnderage buyers occur iviL 1?ee the influence azaa'ar procu_r ours i~rogrc sesi, thanrelation- done by :these students beeliuic teferred to the local licensing ing alcohol for a minor.: shins bra riio Arid rxiore the. scenes! Flair, ca turzies wuthority for adrn n~ tive The..: 'Reading Police. -onfused; both onstage and toff. make up, construction, a4d rur action Addition~liy, a! criirii Depart g nt belie Fes thaf by `,ere.watchitig tt?eiu while crew. auiided ofl:tlie tritaxipl riot .complaint niay be Oe l at canductirig a ariety a7ff pro they; on their stage during of `.this`fa_rce . - in its grea~ness i'oliurn District Court for grains that taxgIt both the a rehearsal .n Act One while It would be remiss riot to I.b,en staff, caught selling alcohol to, access and use of alcolicl by ey behind singe getting tiun those w.h made th s' pta underage buyers, underage - individuals; it ,vfl,1 ready for parformance for possible. A6 tireless work of Reports , an he corn fiance help to a'•oid the problem - Act S\YDI and bad on Stage the Parents Suppoi-~q Sulde-q chcQm eck operations e pub- that come writh underage ~O h real lice interfering "nth Thealer (?ST1 : rid DrQnz° Tat data -under state 13~~, ciinkirig. It is less cxperLSive the eri i1iar cL in ire third Club i eruzers enable iYl meaning. that the identity of and easier to prevent youth act t ch was pct one gain_ P~tglS D_ ma Curb la errrbirp lausinesses checkel and the access to alcohol than to 'Wit-1 the same script lines in on this alterrauve belire ai outcome of each check can k,- investigate the motor vehicle each ACt one actors and play, which a not crriz tnt 6 taihed and published by the crashes, fights, and -other actresses intertwined their. folk ricer cio;d of ~L. nar~ n :media , crime bat iiiiderage drinwig relationships, emotions, and familiar, cou-nferl:ia is 'I iese 1P rty patro s - pmrnotes. i forcement activities ,w l be .752 i-n 4 r d 75 kriplemerited by' i3~adin9 .r tr t Police to prevent and safer * '.:yip W, IRE, k t3isperse underage diIui,rtxig 5 , 3 e q K'-ftytA+`t1P parties, to reduce underage 9, ti F t 4 alccl~ai use gild psoble r Nn Potential criminal 6 fen5f~s tint mayb identme~d during trots nki include but {pptu krriocksT t; party - \t . Westszda ripen concept9 are not limited to rotecti e I Jti tadratirr 2 1 12;batFi C In po vial Tealur~s an love'' tistad~ triinor in SS o Sion T - urgekitchen & dir. area open container, driving under ~ a I .slat{dets tt clack oyer~aak f the influence, and.For procur s f Mg tit;~e ~~f~n~ed yard Dig alcohol fo a minor. y =-liardwoDrl floors ist ftoQr. _ t} - ewEy I Ftir. erzm nal offenses, a ; laundry: T, at iz r nzil aplairip - ? rnse hi fay.. rrn fro5bly ~mi n painted F nk-V?.Wha+ 'h$R, i'4 dli~cl, t obura District Court _ :r' ,u>Ik ill Closet & master J -1 C~G411 b. - ,~;y tiG1A1 U.~Tr~P.-..$5! J1H'N'M I l '1 Sun~elllatzce pa*,xt~Is ~ ~ -~9 deg- tic 'ili nionit or t. e m 1 Lineal Updated 4 bed hx aHO L it out'H e ioirr bath multJ level. Newer ~ F,itcben `wft ir,Ch,cabinets & r i i~ center island, brand ne2w ` . s _ aPP,iGarrccfs fcest~ly } ! F a~rted, be rodt; i plated eltrici eurity system. sx' 3~ l F TdwGt4?d Jtoors t# rough -~~3jj , ocr pscri rp~(pmy GgverljcaQ king.(. c ~~w / 3r{V lf'VV{JR14}1arR/ rJt7VU Ole: 535_1534 41. 4 5. .11 Reading Police Announce 2011 Underage Drinking Crackdown - Reading, MA Patch Page 1 of 2 a i a 7 7, Editor Matt Casey: Reading assistant principal takes her skills to North Reading. #ReadingMA Patch htSo:Ilf6.melzvi6uovT -Tweeted 12 minutes ago Get the Patch Newsletter Sign Up Log In Change Towns Want yogi' nails treated like Royalty7 15% Off Any Nail service B 233 Haven 6.. (976)604-6571 Police & Fire Reading Police Announce 2011 Underage Drinking Crackdown Measures include compliance checks and party patrols. March 14, 2011 Print 0 Comments Email Tweet View full size Tell Your Neliahbors-About Patch '''"`Press Release" The Reading Police Department will conduct a variety of underage alcohol enforcement operations in 2011. These operations may include Cops in Shops, underage stings/compliance checks, party patrols, and surveillance patrols. An overview of each type of operation is described below: Cops in Shops© - This operation typically consists of one undercover officer who works inside the store while a second officer is positioned outside the establishment to apprehend adults that procure alcohol for youths. Cops in Shops® places the focus on the perpetrators - minors that try to purchase alcohol illegally and adults that try to purchase alcohol illegally for minors. Signs are placed in stores prior to the operation to notify patrons of the possible presence of undercover officers. Underage stings/compliance checks- Underage, young adults under the direction of Reading Police will come into local businesses during the year to try to buy alcoholic beverages. Police officers will be working with these youths. Businesses where sales to underage buyers occur will be referred to the local licensing authority for administrative action. Additionally, a criminal complaint may be filed at Woburn District Court for staff caught selling alcohol to underage buyers. Reports on compliance check operations become public data under State law, meaning that the identity of businesses checked and the outcome of each check can be obtained and published by the news media. Party patrols- Enforcement activities will be implemented by Reading Police to prevent and safely disperse underage drinking parties to reduce underage alcohol use and problems. Potential criminal offenses that may be identified during party patrols may include but are hot limited to: protective' custody, minor in possession, open container, driving under the influence, and/or procuring alcohol for a minor. For criminal offenses, a criminal complaint maybe filed at Woburn District Court or Lowell Juvenile Court. Surveillance patrols- Reading Police will monitor locations throughout the community to gather information on potential underage drinking violations' These locations may include local sporting events, town conservation land, parking areas, and other areas identified as "hot spots". Potential criminal offenses that may be identified during party patrols may include but are not limited to: http://reading.patch.com/articles/reading-police-announce-2011-underage-drinking-crackd... 6/27/2011 Reading Police Announce 2011 Underage Drinldng Crackdown. - Reading, MA Patch Page 2 of 2 protective custody, minor in possession, open container, driving under the influence; and/or procuring alcohol for a minor. For criminal offenses, a criminal complaint may be filed at Woburn District Court or Lowell Juvenile Court. The Reading Police Department believes that by conducting a variety of programs that target both the access and use of alcohol by underage individuals;. it will help to avoid the problems that come with underage drinking, it is less expensive and easier to prevent youth access to alcohol than to investigate the motor vehicle crashes, fights, and other crime that underage drinking promotes. Communities that have reduced the availability of alcohol to underage drinkers have experienced fewer crashes and fewer crimes. Preventing underage drinking is everyone's responsibility! Interested in a follow-up to this article? Ertel your email addre>s J~,~'z~ Recommend Zl recommendations, sign up to see what send your friends recommend. Email Tweet Follow this article Submit a tip Add photos & video Leave a comment Submit, yyI ~1~ I tmv Q'I~ecBur~ Brofte s2f31~3aa$Q i' 14--~O- tiro .olecfc ats7inna~rta4x+a:cam Advertise Advertise on Patch and reach potential customers In your backyard and beyond. Click here for more information. Learn more n Volunteer If you want to help local causes, or your cause needs local help, your next click should be right here. Learn more Contribute s Send us news tips e Put an event on the calendar s Announce something to everyone Patch Info Get in Touch bout Us Help Jobs Contact Us Advertise Patch Blog Terms of Use Privacy Policy Copyright © 2011 Patch. All Rights Reserved. Patch Initiatives Goodies PatchlJ Newsletters Patc o Widgets t4 Network http://reading.patch.com/articles/reading-police-announce-201 1-underage-drinkihg-crackd... 6/27/2011 What did the town do prior to violations? • On 5/26/2011 Officers visited: Sam's Bistro, Oye's, Roman's, Chili's, Fuddruckers, Longhorn and Bertucci's. Officers talked with managers regarding alcohol compliance. ® On. 5/27/2011 Officers visited: The Wine Shop, Venetian Moon, Grumpy Doyle's, Pavorottis, Caf6 Capri, Mandarin'(Wine Bunker was closed). Officers talked with managers regarding alcohol compliance. OFFIC)ER'S NAME PROGRAM AREA (compliance check, TIME @ up to 4 hour DATE party atrol etc. block Mark Segalla 5/25/2011 Party Patrols 8 p.m.- 12 p.m. Michelle Halloran 5/25/2011 Party Patrols 8 p.m.- 12 p.m. Derek Holmes 5/26/2011 Surveillance Patrols 8 .m.- 12 p.m. Pat Iapicca 5/27/2011 Surveillance Patrols 8 p.m.- 12 p.m. Michael Saunders 5/26/2011 Surveillance Patrols 8 p.m.- 12 p.m. Corey Santasky 5/27/2011 Surveillance Patrols 8 p.m.- 12 p.m. From 5125/11-5/27/11 ® Officers also conducted surveillance of potential underage drinking areas, no issues found. ® Officers conducted party patrols of underage drinking areas, no issues found. Planning/Coordination with RCASA and Town Staff: ® Officers met in May to be trained on the new "TIP411 text a tip" program. The program will increase info sharing between local residents and police. Residents may submit a tip via text or through the web. The program will launch in July 2011. ® Sgt. Det. Segalla and Erica McNamara participated in the mandatory grant training offered by the Highway Safety Division to ensure all operations would be conducted properly. ® The Annual Press Release announcing the 2011 Compliance Checks was submitted to the media. ® RCASA conducted TIPS (Responsible Beverage Service) training for Oye's staff on April 28, 2011. 5 staff passed. 1 staff member failed. The results were forwarded to the town manager and Oye's Manager. The TIPs Program allows participants that fail to re-take the class within. 6 months of their class. The program requires that participants get a 70 or above to pass the exam. ® RCASA conducted TIPs training for Wine Bunker staff in January 2011. All staff passed. ® RCASA conducted TIPs training for VFW staff in December 2010. 2 staff failed. The Town Manager conducted annual visits to the licenses in late fall of 2010. He let managers know that TIPs training was available through RCASA. Page 1 of 2 McNamava, Erica From: McNamara, Erica Sent: Tuesday, December 21, 2010 12:25 PM To: 'mlt50@comcast.net' Subject: exam results Hi Dawn, The following is the results of your TIPs class. I am sorry to report that 2 participants did not pass their exams. They have the opportunity to retake a class within the next 6 months to try again. I will check with TIPs to see if there are any trainings coming up soon and will be in touch to coordinate this process. Congrats to you and the others that completed the course! 'I will be in touch... Trained at/for: Reading Overseas Veterans, Inc. 575 Main St Reading, MA 01867-3135 Jurisdiction: MA Date Held: 12/12/2010 Date Received: 12/16/2010 Date Processed: 12/20/2010 No. Participants: 6 No. Passed: 4 No. Failed: 2 No. Retakes: 0 Course: TIPS On Premise 2919710 N Pass: N CARL SULLO Reading Overseas Veterans, Inc. 575 Main St, Reading, MA 01867-3135 2919711 N Pass: Y Expires: 12/12/2013 CARL FENNELLY Reading Overseas Veterans, Inc. 575 Main St, Reading, MA 01867-3135 cfennellyl@comcast.net 2919712 N Pass: Y Expires: 12/12/2013 MICHAEL HOFFER Reading Overseas Veterans, Inc. 575 Main St, Reading, MA 01867-3135 2919713 N Pass: Y Expires: 12/12/2013 THOMAS FENNELLY Reading Overseas Veterans, Inc. 575 Main St, Reading, MA 01867-3135 tafen.nel:ly@comcast. net 2919714 N Pass: N RICHARD REDMOND Reading Overseas Veterans, Inc. 575 Main St, Reading, MA 01867-3135 2919715 N Pass: Y Expires: 12/12/2013 DAWN FENNELLY Reading Overseas Veterans, Inc. 575 Main St, Reading, MA 01867-3135 mlt50@comcast.net 6/27/2011 HEALTH COMMUNICATIONS INC. Trainer. Erica McNamara (51732) Date Held: 04128/2011 For State: MA Total: 6 No. Passed: 5 No. Retakes: 0 (N = New, R = Retake) Course:. TIPS Participant On Premise Session ID: 256282 Rush? N Invoice 0 2994837 N Fail WILLIAM PHUNG Expires: 26 Lake St 2994838 N Pass AIPING KE Expires: 4128/2014 235 Arlington St 2994839 N Pass YONG YANG Expires: 4/28/2014 15 Standish Ave rya02l70@hotmaii.com 2994840 N Pass CHEN XUE Expires: 412812014 138 Elmwood Ave bad-xiaotu89@hotmaii.com 2994641 N Pass XIAOJUN CHEN Expires: 4/28/2014 97 Safford Si Apt 3 xiaojun3320@gmail.com 2994842 N Pass WAN YE Expires: 4/28/2014 26 Walkers Brook Dr Processed: 05109/2011 No. Failed: 1 No. Printed: 6 Received: 05/03/2011 Oye's Restaurant and Bar Maiden, MA 02148-1950 Oye's Restaurant and Bar Quincy, MA 02170-1705 Oye's Restaurant and Bar Quincy, MA 02170-2609 Oye's Restaurant and Bar Quincy, MA 02170-1418 Oye's Restaurant and Bar Quincy, MA 02170-1050 Oye's Restaurant and Bar Reading, MA 01867-3224 Note: Due to state privacy restrictions, Social Security Number is now only listed when required by state law Printed on: 5/10/2011 DD:RINC6 READING POLICE DEPARTMENT 06/22/11 23:13 v5.5n PAGE: 1 INVESTIGATIVE ACTION REPORT CASE#: D084218 org.case#: rpt date: 06/22/11 22:37 reported: WEDNESDAY 06/.22/11 18:30 from date: to ucr: 957 DET SPECIAL ASSIGNMENT location: ABCC COMPLIANCE follow up by: NONE NEEDED case status: CLEARED NORMAL officer: rpt status: COMPLETE Change Status: review officer: 53 SGT DET SEGALLA comp/vict notify: N sup-review officer: cir/involve type: Solvability Factors CIR: complaint: ABCC GRANT (COMPLIANCE CHECKS) reporting second officer: 72 officer: •64 S.R.O. SANTASKY DET. HALLORAN assignment: C car: 72 sup/back-up: 53 SGT DET SEGALLA NAMES INVOLVED 120768 ZHENG,JIAN QING INVOLVED 122781 PENGMA,PAPHADA - INVOLVED 122782 TUNG,WAI INVOLVED 122785 OYE'S, 2.6 WALKERS BROOK READING MA 01867 INVOLVED 122786 SPICE,BANGKOK 76 HAVEN READING MA 01867 NARRATIVE The following is a summary of facts of an incident that occurred on 06/22/2011. I was working with Sgt Det. Segalla and Detective Halloran conducting alcohol compliance checks of all the restaurants 7 5.5n CASE#: D084218 .case#: READING POLICE DEPARTMENT INVESTIGATIVE ACTION REPORT 06/22/11. 23:13 PAGE: 2 NARRATIVE and lounges in Reading. At approximately 7:00 pm Sgt Det. Segalla, the Criminal Division Commander conducted a training for our under age operative, Kelly During the training she was photographed and given aportable breath test that registered 0.0. She was given $20.00 for the purpose of the compliance checks and left all other property secured in the police station. The training was completed at approximately 7:15 pm. Ms. was assigned to both Sgt. Segalla and myself. We conducted our first check at the Venetian Moon located at 680 Main Street. At 7:26 pm Ms. INgagM entered the establishment empty handed. At 7:27 pm she exited the establishment empty handed..She stated that an identification was requested by the clerk and she left the establishment. At 7:28 pm Ms. wow" entered Restorante Pavarotti located at 601 Main Street. At 7:30 pm she exited the establishment. She stated that an identification was requested by the bartender and she left the establishment. At 7:33 pm Ms. entered Bangkok Spice located.at 76.Haven Street. At 7:33pm Sgt. Segalla and I observed Ms. ORURO= sit down at a table and a waitress walk up to her and speak to her. The waitress then walked away and several moments later returned to Ms. FAMMIMMI table with a l2oz.Bud Light bottle. At this time, we observed two waitresses speaking to Ms. ENERIM. At this time, we entered the restaurant..Ms. stated that she was served one 12oz Bud Light Bottle. She stated that the waitress served her the drink without requesting identification. She made a positive identification of the waitress by painting and stating "that's her, the waitress standing at the entrance to the kitchen." Ms. aglZanon returned to our vehicle while Sgt. Segalla and I approached the waitress. We identified ourselves as Reading Police Officers and asked to talk to her.in private. The waitress was identified as Ms. Paphada Pengma ( of Massachusetts. Ms. Pengma was made aware.of the operation and that she had sold alcohol to a minor without requesting identification. Ms. Pengma stated she did serve her and was sorry. Sgt. Segalla asked Ms. P'engma to speak with the restaurant manager. The manager was identified as Mr. Palarat Pattanesuan ( ) of Massachusetts. Mr. Pattanesuan was made aware of the operation and that the waitress had sold alcohol to a minor without requesting identification. Mr. Pattanesuan was advised by Sgt Segalla that a report of the incident will be forwarded to the local liquor licensing board for a hearing due to the violation. DD.RINC6 v5. 5n CASE#: D084218 org.case#: READING POLICE DEPARTMENT 06/22/11 23:13. PAGE: 3 INVESTIGATIVE ACTION REPORT s- NARRATIVE At 7:43 pm Ms. entered Columbo's - Restaurant located. at 2 Brande Court. At 7:44 pm she exited the establishment. She stated that the clerk informed her that they no longer sell alcohol beverages. At 7:48 pm Ms.661001100 entered Cafe' Capri located at 355 Main Street. At 7:48 pm she exited the establishment. She stated that an identification was requested. by the bartender and she left the establishment. At 7:58 pm Ms.WEEREOUD entered Grumpy Doyle's Bar located at 530 Main Street.'At 7:59 pm she exited the establishment. She stated that an identification was requested by the bartender and she left the establishment. At 8:01 pm Ms entered Sam's Bistro located at 107 Main Street. At 8:02 pm she exited the establishment. She stated ''that an identification was' requested by the bartender and she left the establishment. At 8:08 pm Ms. entefikEr`vibddruckers Restaurant located at 50 Walkers Brook Drive. At 8:12 pm she exited the establishment. She stated that an identification was requested by the clerk and she left the establishment. At 8:14 pm Ms. entered Chilli's Restaurant located at 70 Walkers Brook.Drive. At 8:15 pm she exited the establishment. She' stated that an identification was requested by the bartender and she left.the establishment. At 8:17 pm Ms. 'tntered macaroni Bar and Grill located at 48 Walkers Brook Drive. At 8:18 pm she exited the estabiishment. She stated that an identification was requested by the bartender and she left the establishment. At 8:18 pm Ms. entered Oye's Restaurant" ocated at 26 Walkers Brook Drive. At 8:21 pin`°she exited the establishment. She stated that she-was served one 12oz Bud Light Bottle. After being served she stated the bartender took the $20.00 bill she produced and gave her $16.25 back. She stated that the bartender served her the drink without requesting identification. Ms. MIENJUP was brought to the entrance of the establishment by myself. She made a positive identification of the bartender by pointing and stating "that's him, the bartender with the bald head, glasses and black shirt standing inside the bar." Ms. returned to our vehicle while I approached the hostess. I identified myself as a Reading Police Officer and asked to talk to his manager. The manager was identified as Ms. Jian Qing Zheng ) of Massachusetts. DD.RINC6 READING POLICE DEPARTMENT 06/22/11 23:13 v5.5n PAGE: 4 INVESTIGATIVE ACTION REPORT CASE#: D084218 org.case#: NARRATIVE Ms. Zheng was made aware of the operation and that the bartender had sold alcohol to•a minor without requesting identification. Ms. Zheng then brought the bartender over to speak with me. He was identified as Mr. Wai Tung ) of Massachusetts. Mr. Tung. was made aware of the operation and that he had sold alcohol to a minor without requesting identification. Mr: Tung stated that the minor walked up to him, asked for a drink and that he thought she was sitting at a table and served her a Bud-Light. Ms. Zheng was advised by me that. a report of the incident will be forwarded to the local liquor licensing board for a hearing due to the violation. At 8:30 pm Ms. entered Bertucci's Restaurant located at 45 Walkers Brook Drive. At 8:31 pm she exited the establishment. She stated that an identification was requested by the bartender and she left the establishment. At 8:31 pm Ms. CEMNIEW entered Longhorns Grill located at 39 Walkers Brook Drive. At 8:32 pm she exited the establishment. She stated that an identif'icati'on was requested by the bartender and she left the establishment. At 8:37 pm Ms: QNEWS entered Mandarin Restaurant located at 296 Salem St. At 8:37 pm she exited the establishment. She stated that an identification was requested by the bartender. Ms. photo and PBT results (0.0) were again taken at the station. Violations: M.G.L. Ch138, &34 - Sale or Delivery of an alcoholic beverage to a person les.s than twenty-one years of age (2 Counts). A copy of this report will be forwarded to the.Liquor Licensing Board to conduct a hearing into the matter. Solvability Factors - Eliminated by Investigation: Developed by Investigation.: Remaining for Investigation: Additional Evidence/Tech Work.- Photographs [ ] Composite ] Fingerprints [ ] Other [ ] Performed by: gen status: DD.RINC6 READING POLICE DEPARTMENT 06/22/11 23:13 v5.5n PAGE: 5 INVESTIGATIVE ACTION REPORT CASE#: D084218 org.case#: nv gating Officer's Signature DD.RINC6 . v5 . 5n CASE#: D084229 org.case#: READING POLICE DEPARTMENT INVESTIGATIVE ACTION REPORT 06/27/11 10:2B PAGE: 1 rpt date: 06/23/11 21:31 reported: THURSDAY 06/23%11 19:00 from date: to ucr: 957 DET SPECIAL ASSIGNMENT location: ABCC COMPLIANCE CHKS follow up by: NONE NEEDED case status: OPEN officer: rpt status: PRELIMINARY Change Status: review officer: comp/vict notify: N sup review officer: cir/involve type: Solvability Factors CIR: complaint: DETECTIVES WORKING ABCC COMPLIANCE CHECK reporting officer: 54 DET. HOLMES assignment: C car: 54 second officer: 31 DET. IA.PICCA sup/back-up: 3.6 DET. SAUNDERS NAMES type mast# name/add phone dob ss# INVOLVED 025145 KELLEY,JUDITH M INVOLVED 06774,6 FERGUSON,JOHN o j'[F/ o,"o3co COX✓ li ' INVOLVED 091116 FASKOM MICHAEL PROPERTY prop.type make mod/style color ser#/vin# EVIDENCE rpt'd: 06/23/11 class: 02 ALCOHOL BUD LIGHT BLUE id/desc: SIX PACK OF BUD LIGHT CANS 120 value: $0. ncic: reg 080439 - WINE SHOP OF READING control bin analy gen note: SEIZED AS EVIDENCE FROM UNDERAGE ALCOHOL PURCHASE STING NARRATIVE On Thursday 6/23/11, I along with Detectives. Mike Saunders and Pat Iapicca conducted alcohol compliance checks.of Reading's liquor Y ;AINC 6 1 v5. 5n CASE#:. D084229 org.case#: 06/27/11 10:28 PAGE: 2 stores, Veteran's clubs, and the Knights of Columbus Hall during the hours of 7pm and 11pm. Our main objective that evening was to check to make sure that retail liquor stores, veteran's clubs, and fraternal organizations were not selling alcohol to minors under 21 years of age and checking for valid forms of identification. READING POLICE DEPARTMENT INVESTIGATIVE ACTION REPORT NARRATIVE At or around 7:00pm we started our operation. We used Michael QMKIMM dob as our underage operative to conduct the compliazice'checks . did so voluntarily. Before beginning, we conducted a brief training for 9INIEft in which he was photographed and administered a portable breath test to check his sobriety in which he registered a BAC of 0. 0. We explained to IsEfflEa what we expected of him and he was given $20 cash from the department to use. was, checked before going into the establishments to make sure he did not have any identification or money. His wallet was left in our cruiser during the operation. Over the course of the next four hours we sent Vdl~ into Busa's Liquors at 345 Main St, Square Liquors at 11 High St, Northside Liquors 150 Main St, and The Wine Shop at 676 Main St. He was instructed to attempt to purchase a six pack of bud light beer. The Wine Bunker at 1 General Way closed at.8pm and we were unable to perform the check. - At or around 7:54pm NOMEM entered the-Wine Shop at 676 Main St and took a six pack of bud light cans to the check out counter. He stated that the female clerk engaged him in conversation asking him if he was a "Reading cop". She then stated that she would "put the, beers in a bag so the Reading Police wouldn't see him with the beers in the open". He paid $6.49 for the beers in cash and left the store and reported immediately back to.us"° stated that she never asked him for any identification. Detectives Iapicca and Saunders along with ONMEMS went back into the store and pointed out the clerk who served him to them. She was identified by the Detectives as Judith Kelly dob IN01M 03 MA.'They informed Kelly of the compliance checks qINNEIN and she stated that she sold to him because @MEMEEM engaged her in conversation about beers and wine and it confused her. stated to us that he never had any conversation with Kelly.. Kelly admitted to the detectives that.she never asked •for any identification. We also sent into the Reading Overseas Veterans club at 575 Main St, Knights of Columbus 11 Sanborn St, and the American Legion Post at 37 Ash St. He was instructed to attempt to purchase a single bud light beer. We. were unable to perform a check at the Meadow Brook Country Club at.292 Grove St as it was closed for the evening. DD.R±NC6 READING POLICE DEPARTMENT 06/27/11 10:28 v5.5n PAGE: 3 INVESTIGATIVE ACTION REPORT CASE#: D084229 org.case#: NARRATIVE At or around 8:30pm MqOlgaM went into the Knights of Columbus located at 11 Sanborn St. He rang the outside,buzzer and was let in. Once inside he proceeded to the bar and ordered a Budweiser beer. He was served by the male bartender and stated that he paid $2.50 and then walked out and reported to us that he was served. Detectives Saunders, Iapicca and I along with SNUMOMh went inside the Knight of Columbus. pointed out the male bartender to us who served him and left. We proceeded over to the bartender and identified ourselves as Reading Police Officers and why we were there. The bartender identified himself as John Ferguson dob MEM MA. Ferguson stated to us that he did not ask for any identification and he should have. Further he stated that IMMIJEW never paid for the beer. Once outside we asked IMENISM again if he paid for the beer and he stated that he did. At the end of the operation 's picture was taken again and he was administered another breath test which showed his BAC to be 0.0. He also gave us the remaining money back from the initial $20 which was $11.01; $6:49 for the six pack at the Wine Shop and $2.50 for the single beer at the K of C. Pictures of along with his RMV and BOP are included with this report. Violations: MGL (c)138 - (s)34 Sale or Delivery of an alcoholic beverage to a person under the age.of 21 years of age (2 counts). Solvability Factors - Eliminated by Investigation: Developed by Investigation: Remaining for Investigation: Additional Evidence/Tech Work - Photographs [ ] Composite [ ] Fingerprints [ Performed byc other [ gen status: / 3 ' ~ L:-:~9~~ I a~_ - 266Y Investigating ~ .P Signature e ewing Offi C Date DD.RINC6 READING POLICE DEPARTMENT v5.5n INVESTIGATIVE ACTION REPORT CASE#: D084240 org.case#: rpt date: 06/24/11 16:07 reported:. FRIDAY from date: to ucr: 957 DET SPECIAL ASSIGNMENT location: follow up by: NONE ,NEEDED officer: Change Status : camp/vict notify: N cir/involve type: Solvability Factors CIR:. case status: rpt status: review officer: sup review officer: 06/24/11 16:09 PAGE: 1 06/24/11 14:45 OPEN PRELIMINARY complaint: ALCOHOL COMPLIANCE CHECK reporting officer: 36 DET. SAUNDERS assignment: B car: 36 second officer: 54 DET. HOLMES sup/back-up: NAMES type. mast# name/add phone dob ss#----- INVOLVED 091116 ,MICHAELL NARRA'T'IVE ON FRIDAY, JUNE 24,2011, DETECTIVE HOLMES AND MYSELF, ALONG WITH MICHAEL r-NdERIM CONDUCTED TWO ALCOHOL,COMPLIANCE CHECKS AT THE WINE BUNKER, ONE GENERAL WAY, READING MA AND MEADOWBROOK GOLF CLUB, 292 GROVE STREET, READING MA. OUR MAIN OBJECTIVE TODAY W geTO CHECK TO MAKE SURE THAT THE WINE BUNKER AND MEADOWBROOK GOLD CLUB BAR WAS NOT SELLING ALCOHOL TO MINORS UNDER 21 YEARS OF AGE AND WERE CHECKING FOR VALID FORMS OF IDENTIFICATION. AT APPROXIMATELY 1445 HOURS WE STARTED OUR OPERATION. WE USED MICHAEL 'MISEM, DOB JIMMEMEM AS OUR UNDERAGE OPERATIVE TO CONDUCT THE COMPLIANCE CHECKS. DID SO VOLUNTARILY. BEFORE BEGINNING, WE CONDUCTED A BRIEF TRAINING FOR IN WHICH.HE.VIA,S PHOTOGRAPHED AND ADMINISTRATED A PORTABLE BREATH TEST TO CHECK SOBRIETY IN WHICH HE REGISTERED A BAC OF 0.0. WE. EXPLAINED TO1. WHAT WE EXPECTED OF HIM AND HE WAS GIVEN $20 CASH FROM THE DEPARTMENT TO USE. jOINEMM WAS ASKED TO REMOVE ALL HIS PERSONAL BELONGINGS AND WAS PATTED DOWN. TO MAKE SURE HE HAD NO ID'S OR MONEY ON HIM. HIS BELONGINGS WERE PLACED IN MY FILE CABINET AND SECURED. ON 6/24/2011, AT APPROXIMATELY 1501 HOURS, MICHAEL%MIMMW WENT INTO. THE WINE BUNKER, LOCATED AT ONE GENERAL WAY.', READING MA. THE WINE DD.RINC6 READING POLICE DEPARTMENT 06/24/11 16.:09 v5.5n PAGE: 2 INVESTIGATIVE ACTION REPORT CASE#: D084240 org.case#: NARRATIVE BUNKER ONLY SELLS WINE. MICHAEL SELECTED A BOTTLE OF WINE AND ATTEMPTED TO PURCHASE IT. THE SALES CLERK ASKED MICHAEL FOR HIS ID AND HE STATED THAT HE DID NOT HAVE IT. THE SALES CLERK REFUSED TO SELL THE WINE TO MICHAEL. ON 6/24/2011, AT APPROXIMATELY 1509 HOURS, MICHAEL ,,WENT INTO THE BAR AT MEADOWBROOK GOLF CLUB, 292 GROVE STREET, READING MA. MICHAEL ATTEMPTED TO BUY A BUD LIGHT BEER FROM THE BARTENDER. THE BARTENDER REQUESTED MICHAEL'S ID. MICHAEL STATED.THAT HE DID NOT HAVE ONE AND HE WAS REFUSED SERVICE. AT THE END OF THE OPERATION eNDFAMS PICTURE WAS TAKEN AGAIN AND HE WAS ADMINISTERED ANOTHER BREATH TEST WHICH SHOWED HIS BAC TO BE 0.0. MICHAEL RETURNED THE $20 I GAVE HIM AND MICHAEL'S BELONGINGS WERE RETURNED TO HIM. Solvability Factors Eliminated by Investigation: Developed by Investigation: Remaining for Investigation: Additional Evidence/Tech Work - Photographs [ ] Composite [ Performed by: Officer's Si ] Fingerprints [ ] other [ ] -r ~ 1 1 c4 ~r Date Oj'kI,I~ R.EY.DING POLICE, DtvAKfmFN-' ~rG4a;- OFFICE OF THE CHIEF ~eus twcoe'vua~.- lb union Strcct, Reading, Nlarsachusettc 01867 lantee U! Cnr»cier Emergrnrc Only: 91I All Other Calls: 781-944-1212 Fcti : 181-944-2893 Cbwj ,t Pohpe F-Mail JCormiertt?r.i.reading.ma.us COMPLIANCE CHECK UNDERAGE PHOTO SHEET AND BREATHALYZER RESULTS f i ~ £ ~ ~ ~ C ~ S1 t c~k ~ t1 C r k . ~4C''~pr Ktl ~ s fI Test CC' k-~1 t2~ Start Time: f C s Result: C% . C, c?C j PBT Operator: 1 Test C-• , End Time: - , I 'l P.4\ Result: c i C-t 1.2c, PBT Operator: 1")! Gt ?t% PHOTO #1 PHOTO #2 OF R% 4 READING POLICE DEPARTmFNTT OFFICE OF THE CMEF ~a irc0NgO~r' 15 Union Street. Reading, 3las3achusetls 01867 Jamee W. Cornier Emergency Only: 911 All Other Calls: 781-944-1212 Fax: 781.944-2893 Mef of PoLe E-Mail: JCormier@ci.reading.ma.us COMPLIANCE CHECK UNDERAGE PHOTO SHEET AND BREATHALYZER RESULTS PHOTO #1 Test Start Time: Lj j; Result: _f C cc PBT Operator: PHOTO #2 Test End Time:; Result: ('5 • r PBT Operator_ f~ ~ ~ r ~ ~ /J/ C v T L3"~ (sk y q- ~ y ~f i j~ - f C O l z +i r 4 t ' - ~ r ~ i ~ }}A t G 1 1 Kea ~1 '`ik~ ✓ 7 _ ~ r ~ s rc '~'`'r nl~'~{i~o~ Yry35 } r f 1 ~ _ ~ ~ ~ ~ J ~~3 41 3 j, '.4r o: R64G~ READING POLICE DEPARTI IEIS7 ~e ~p 4 OFFICE OF THE CHIEF ncnwp°~' li _nton Street. Reading, NLL%nachuncrts 01867 ,Jame W. CoIm[Cr Emergency Only: 911 All Other U- Is! 781-944-1.212 Pax: 781-944.2893 Cbuf of Pabca F Flail: JCormier(ooci.read img.ma.us COMPLIANCE CHECK UNDERAGE PHOTO SHEET AND BREATHALYZER RESULTS PHOTO #1 PHOTO #2 Breathalyzer I.D. k)k Underage Operative Name: Date: Test Test Start Time: End Time: Result- Result: 1. ) PBT Operator: PBT Operator: 1 ~ 1 r ~i 'z a li: ] ; ~ s' j . ~ R ~ ~ r ~ F~ ` k} tt } 3 ~ i ~ r i 7 ~ i,~ C,: _ ~ ~,f ' c___. , ~L _ ~r ~~9;~IN~ORP✓i~ Jajtw W. Cornzier Chief of Police READING Poum DEPARTmEN T OFFICE OF THE CHEF 15 Union Street, Reading, Massachusetts 01867 Emergency Only,. 911 All Other Calls: 781-944-1212 Fax: 781-944-2893 E-Mail: JCormier@ci.reading.ma.us LIQUOR COMPLIANCE CHECK GUIDELINES These guidelines are intended to provide the basic framework, which will be used when conducting underage liquor compliance checks on licensed premises. 1) Notification through the local media that the Town of Reading will continue to monitor licensed establishments by conducting periodic compliance checks. 2) The underage person taking part in the sting should reasonably look their age. Efforts to make them appear older should be avoided. 3) A photo of underage person should be taken and attached to the information requested in #6. 4) The underage person should not be carrying any identification when taking part in the sting. 5) The underage person should not carry any money with. them other than that given by the Town of Reading Detective or Police Officer supervising them. 6) The underage person shall sign a release form prior the starting participation in this program. The underage person and the Town of Reading Detective or Police Officer or any other law enforcement officer should also sign and date a copy of these guidelines. 7) Unless circumstances warrant, the underage person shall be given a B.A.C test at the beginning and at the conclusion of the investigation. They should be informed of this prior to beginning.the investigation. 8) The underage person shall enter the licensed premises under observation by a Town of.Reading Detective or Police Officer.and/or a law enforcement officer. 9) The underage person shall attempt to purchase an alcoholic beverage. They should attempt to purchase the same alcoholic berverage at each location. 10) At no time shall the underage person attempt to misrepresent their age or provide any identification. 11) If asked for identification, the underage person should leave the. establishment. 12) If served at any on-premise establishment, the underage person shall remain on the licensed premises for a period of time instructed by the Town of Reading Detective or Police Officer. They should then exit the licenses premises leaving the alcoholic beverage. If served at an off-premises establishment, the underage person shall carry the alcoholic beverage out to the Town of Reading Detective or Police Officer and/or law enforcement officer. 13) At no time, under any circumstances, shall the underage person consume any alcoholic beverage. 14) The safety and welfare of all underage participants will be of the utmost importance to the Town of Reading Detective or Police Officer and law enforcement personnel. Underage persons shall not be exposed to any unusual, unnecessary or unreasonable risk. 15) The underage person will not wear, exhibit or carry any Town of Reading or law enforcement identification or falsely represent themselves as an employee of the Reading Police Department or any other law enforcement unit while participating in this program. They shall not under any circumstances carry a weapon. 16) Town of Reading Detective or Police Officers and law enforcement personnel should only enter the premises to observe on an as needed basis when circumstances warrant. 17) A Reading Police Officer will enter the, licensed premises after the sting, and notify the manager on duty of said compliance check. UNDERAGE OPERATIVE: Date: LAW ENFORCEMENT OFFICER Date: NOVEMBER 2007 READING POLICE DEPARTMENT zd k 15 Union Street ° Reading, Massachusetts 0.1867 +tucoxno Emergency Only: 911 ° All Other Calls: (781) 944-1212 ° Fax: (781) 944-2893 www.ei.reading.ma.us/police/ Requesting hearings for violations of MGL cl38 s34 Sale or Delivery. of an alcoholic beverage to a person less than twenty-one years of age to the following establishments: On June 22, 2011: Bangkok Spice Thai Restaurant 76 Haven Street Reading, MA 01867 On June 23, 2011: The Wine Shop of Reading 676 Main Street Reading, MA 01867 Oye's Restaurant and Bar 26 Walker's Brook Dr Reading, MA 01867 Knights of Columbus 11 Sanborn Street Reading, MA 01867