Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout2025-09-08 Board of Library Trustees MinutesW a i e' Town of Reading y, Meeting Minutes RECEIVED TOWN CLERK READING, MA. 2025 OCT 15 AM 8 066 Board - Committee - Commission - Council: Board of Library Trustees Date: 2025-09-08 Building: Reading Public Library Address: 64 Middlesex Avenue Purpose: General Meeting Attendees: Members - Present: Time: 7:00 PM Location: Community Room Session: Open Session Version: Final Cappy Popp, Chair; Andrew Grimes, Secretary; Kell[ Bacon; Monette Verner Members - Not Present: Patrick Egan, Vice -Chair; Andrew Gregory Others Present: Amy Lannon, Director; Michelle Alleul, Assistant Director; Meaghan Clemente, Administrative Assistant; Andrea Fiorillo, Head of Public Services; Jamie Penney, Head of Collection Services; Valerie Gould Heithaus, Senior Library Associate; Minutes Respectfully Submitted By: Andrew Grimes, Secretary Topics of Discussion: I. Call to Order 7:02 p.m. II. Public Comment The Board received an email from Allison Sloan, a former Library employee and current president of the Massachusetts Library Trustees Association (MLTA). Board members are encouraged to join MLTA, which provides training and resources for local library trustees. An annual $100 fee would provide membership for the entire Board. For more details, please visit the MLTA's website. Ms. Lannon reminded the Board that additional free training resources are available through the United for Libraries' statewide membership program. The Board will discuss this opportunity further in October. Ms. Lannon presented electric vehicle charging statistics received from the Reading Municipal Light Department. Level 3 fast charging sessions continue to grow. Level 2 charging sessions have decreased slightly, possibly because more users are taking advantage of the faster Level 3 station when available. Parking space lines have been updated to reflect the addition of a regular parking spot. Ms. Vanier noted that although the electric vehicle symbol has been blacked out, faint electric vehicle wording still exists and may cause confusion. Ms. Lannon will follow up on the possibility of a general parking sign to clarify that the space is open to all. Page I t Ill. Fall Programming I Summer Reading Report Andrea Fiorillo, Head of Public Services, presented an update on fall programming and summer reading at the Library. Ms. Fiorillo dishibuted copies of the fall programming brochure to the Board. This year's Branching Out summer reading theme aligned with the Rooted in Reading grant. In line with this focus on nature and sustainability, the program aimed to minimize material waste in favor of a stronger emphasis on reading and connections. Activities included writing workshops, silent reading parties, and a story slam. Adults and teens submitted shelf talkers and book blurbs to help promote materials throughout the collection. Children's survey results show that 60% of respondents liked this year's summer reading program more than previous years. Summer reading helps promote reading as a fun activity by incorporating the Library into a daily routine. Summer reading provides opportunities to socialize and make new friends while also combating the summer slide, a regression in reading ability and academic progress during summer breaks from school. Various lectures, workshops, and events are planned for the fall: • A presentation in partnership with Braver Angels will help attendees better understand differences in political beliefs and respectfully find common ground. • Workshops on pickles, tea blending, and coffee tasting • A children's Halloween costume swap • A November screening of "The Death and Life of Larry Benson" and a community conversation in honor of Veterans' Day • A presentation by Local Historian and Author William M. Fowler Jr. on his newest book, George Washington and the Creation of the American Republic • A Korean myths and folklore author talk with Jihyun Yuri and Ryan Estrada • A special storytime featuring live goats Library Associate Alissa Landau will once again lead a popular Mah Jongg instructional series, which many patrons requested over the summer. This program series remains in high demand, as the registration and waitlist are already full. RPL will also offer a "Mortality 101" series on death and dying based on a similar series in the fall of 2016. Activities include • Write Your Own Obituary workshops • Two board -certified Elder Law attorneys will present on end -of -life planning. • A Digital Afterlife workshop will focus on managing the digital assets and online profiles of loved ones. • A Death Caf6 will provide a safe and respectful space, with refreshments, to openly discuss the challenging topic of death. Children's events include a monthly toddler yoga series, an Act It Out Storybook Theater series, and a Start Up Squad and Shark Tank Jr. entrepreneurship series. Family concerts will feature performances by Little Groove, Marian Iranzi, Mara & Motoko, Rockabye Beats, Sulinha's Trio, and Peter Sheridan. RPL will host the Connected Reading community open house on Tuesday, October 28, after the annual downtown trick -or -treating event. A Teen Book Group will launch, along with a new Reading Rocket tween and parent book group. One-on-one technology help appointments will now be offered in addition to individual genealogical research appointments. Page 12 The Town's Public Health Nurse, Olivia Bartolomei, is collaborating with the Library to host CPR classes, flu clinics, blood pressure and hearing screenings, and a special Teen Talks event featuring fun hands-on activities with opportunities for discussion and learning about heafth-related issues. In addition to ongoing virtual author talks through the Friends Speaker Series, knit and crochet meetups, and Between Time activities for children ages 9 through 13 will continue. Board game nights for teens and adults will also be held A new Pok6mon Club for children in grades 3 to 5 will also launch. The Board is impressed and supportive of the busy fall programming schedule IV. State of the Collection Head of Collection Services Jamie Penney presented an update on the state of the Library collection. Although circulation remains robust overall, reading trends continue to fluctuate. Generally, the circulation of physical items is trending downward, while the circulation of electronic and digital materials is increasing. Ms. Penney presented circulation statistics for the past three fiscal years, which ran from July 1 through June 30. Total physical circulation includes checkouts, staff renewals, automatic renewals, and web -based patron renewals. Overall circulation has decreased from 343,501 in FY23 to 330,066 in FY25. However, the total circulation of digital books and audiobooks through OverDrlve has increased from 44,552 in FY23 to 55,799 in FY25. Reading is the highest circulating individual Library in the North of Boston Library Exchange (NOBLE) consortium. Only Beverly as a whole has higher circulation, in part due to their larger population, two branch locations, and bookmobile. Reading has the fourth -highest OverDrive circulation in NOBLE- Reading has the eighth -highest number of local patrons in NOBLE, behind only academic libraries and larger cities. Due to federal funding cuts to the Institute of Museum and Library Services (IMLS), there have been cuts to statewide digital resources across Massachusetts. The Library carefully examined usage and cost -per -use statistics, as well as other offerings, and decided that it is most important to provide consistent digital access to the Boston Globe for patrons going forward. Financial Fit and Home Improvement Source have been cancelled for FY26 due to low usage. The amount of Hoopla allowed borrows per patron per month has been reduced from 12 to 9. Newer databases, such as Craft and Hobby, are being promoted to increase usage. The majority of the Library of Things collection is now stored in new cabinet locker shelving on the main floor near the holds pickup area. All items have been reviewed, renamed, and photographed to enhance the browsing experience. The exterior pickup lockers have had their ups and downs in the past, but have been successfully working for several months. The Library has worked with the vendor to reduce screen glare issues, among other technical problems. Senior Library Associate Valerie Gould Heithaus has worked with NOBLE to generate more accurate circulation reports for the lockers. On average, about 60 items are placed in the lockers for outdoor pickup per month. Repeat power users greatly appreciate this convenient pickup option. Ms. Penney demonstrated the features of Aspen, the new public catalog, compared to the standard Evergreen catalog. Aspen provides search assistance and easily groups formats and editions of books. While Evergreen shows separate entries for regular print, large print, a -book, audiobook, and Playaway versions of the same title, these are clearly Page 13 grouped and distinguished in a single entry in Aspen. This feature enables users to easily check availability in their preferred format. On the homepage, a new feature automatically populates with the cover images of new titles, which are easily browsable by category. Collection Services Librarian Kathryn Geoffrion Scannell has coordinated the Aspen transition, which is scheduled to launch in late September officially. Aspen integrates with the Library's mobile application. Mr. Popp noted that physical audio and video circulation has declined in recent years. Ms. Penney explained that newer cars, computers, and laptops do not come with CD players. Many movies and TV shows are no longer being released on DVD, as producers encourage viewers to subscribe to streaming services rather than owning a copy of content. Ms. Penney clarified that the audio format includes audiobook CDs, music CDs, Playaways, and MP3 CDs. Playaways are audiobooks that can be played with just headphones. New items are being added in audio format, as it still circulates quite well overall. However, there are often fewer options available to choose from. V. Review: Revisions to the Collection Development and RFR Policy Ms. Lannon noted that all policies are regularly reviewed to identify opportunities for streamlining and improvement in response to current trends. The Collection Development policy includes the updated RPL Mission Statement in accordancewith the current FY26 — FY30 strategic plan. Other minor changes include adding language from pending Freedom to Reading Massachusetts legislation, reducing duplication of content, and improving clarity. Due to the prevalence of targeted material challenges in recent years, the library staff recommends that a committee of RPL professional librarians address all requests for reconsideration of materials, with the Board serving as the body of appeal. The Library Director and the review committee will review the request, using both qualitative and quantitative data, as well as assessments of the material. If the material meets the selection criteria outlined in the policy, it will not be removed due to any individual or group pressure. The filer of the request for reconsideration then has the option to appeal the decision to the Board. This process enables professionally trained staff to quickly and efficiently research and make informed decisions on the issue. The request for reconsideration form has been adapted to reflect the new process, stating that filers will be notified when a decision has been made. Ms. Lannon clarified that all requests for reconsideration of library materials are considered public record under the Massachusetts Public Records Law. Ms. Venrier noted that other Library policies, such as the Responsibilities Regarding Minors Policy, refer to both parents and caregivers and suggested adopting similar wording to maintain consistency. Specific direction to Appendix 11 for the Request for Reconsideration of Library Materials form and clarification on the procedure for the appeals process is also suggested. Language regarding notification of the decision will be added to Appendix 11. Ms. Lannon noted that these changes reflect staff expertise in the selection process, while still allowing the Board to decide on appealed requests. Although this may open staff selection committees up to additional public criticism, Ms. Fiorillo explained that these changes reflect national trends. Approximately 50% of libraries have appeals processes that include their Board of Library Trustees. Challenging a book is a serious matter that requires careful review by professional staff. Although the staff is grateful for the Board's protection and support, they hope to professionally, and directly address these requests with future filers. Page 14 The Board requested notification of any requests for reconsideration received by the Library so that it can be aware and prepared for any community reactions and responses. Mr. Grimes suggested that the explanation behind any decision be made clear when notifying the filer. Ms. Lannon noted that data, usage, selection criteria, and other elements of the Collection Development policy will be referenced. Appendix II and the request form should be able to stand alone and refer back to the policy. The Board will vote on the proposed edits in October. Ms. Penney, Ms. Gould Heithaus. and Ms. Fiorillo departed the meeting at 755 p.m. VI. Discussion and Vote: Revisions to the Meeting Room Policy Motion: To approve Meeting Room Policy as amended (Verner/Grimes) Vote: Approved 40 VII. Library Terrace Update The Reading Public Library Foundation has generously supported the Library Terrace design and bid process conducted by Activitas. The project went out to bid in July and received eight bids by the due date in August, all of which came in under budget. Ms. Lannon thanked Director of Operations Katie Gabriello, Executive Assistant Joshua Delaune, and Town Engineer Ryan Percival for their hard work and attention to detail throughout the procurement process. The two lowest bidders ultimately withdrew their bids. A contract has been signed for $158,500, which is less than the expected $3550.000 budget for the project. Ms. Lannon is hopeful that the Reading Public Library Foundation will help with additional elements to enhance the project, such as further landscaping and garden maintenance, picnic tables, or other exterior beautification elements in the future. The bonds have been signed, and construction is expected to begin sometime this fall, possibly as early as mid -October. There is a four to six -week lead time for some necessary materials. However, some preparation work for the hardscaping on the terrace seating area can begin ahead of time. If not all plantings can be completed in the fall, they will be installed in the spring. Vill. Financial Report The FY25 Financial Report and State Aid application have been signed and submitted to the Massachusetts Board of Library Commissioners. The Library continues to satisfy all certification requirements. The application was submitted ahead of the October deadline in hopes of hearing about their annual state aid award in November. Several gifts were received in memory of Michael Coltman, the husband of Judy Coltman, an active Friends of the Library member. A gift was also received in recognition of Library Associate Judy Terrazano's recent retirement. Ms. Terrazano continues to work substitute shifts at the Library regularly. IX. Director's Report The Library was excited to prepare for Library Card Signup Month in September. Ms. Filleul summarized recent outreach visits to the Fire and Police Departments, where 12 officers signed up for library cards and expressed enthusiasm about accessing library resources, particularly Libby. The officers, including Cooper the comfort dog, took Page 1 5 pictures to help promote the initiative. Overall, this was a casual and positive way to engage with other town departments. A visit to Town Hall is being planned soon. Ms. Lannon highlighted patron compliments received regarding one-on-one genealogical research with Local History Librarian Jocelyn Gould and eBook technological assistance with Elder Services Librarian Elizabeth Weilbacher. Ms. Lannon acknowledged the challenge of celebrating the positive impact of patron interactions through statistics. Senior Library Associate Dawn Colford celebrates 32 years of service in September. New Library Associate Sam Tincler is an excellent addition to the team with a strong background in customer service. X. Approval of August 11, 2025, Meeting Minutes Motion.: To approve the minutes of the August 11, 2025, Trustee Meeting as written. (Grimes / Verner) Vote: Approved 4-0 - XI. Future Agenda Items In October, the Board will further discuss potential membership in the MLTA. They will also vote on the annual Toys for Tots collection request and the updates to the Collection Development and RFR policy. The Policy on Distribution, Posting, and Collection of Materials will be reviewed. A Town Financial Forum, run by the Finance Committee, is being planned for Wednesday, October 8, at the Library. This event will help identify potential budget issues, review forecasts for state aid and tax revenues, and lay the groundwork for the FY27 municipal budget planning process. The forum will also likely focus on reducing municipal expenses in anticipation of possible future budget overrides. In November, the Level 1 Draft of the FY27 budget will be reviewed. The Board will vote on updates to the Policy on Distribution, Posting, and Collection of Materials. The Gift Policy will also be reviewed as needed. Adjournment 8:07 p.m. Motion: To Adjourn (Vernier/ Bacon) Vote: Approved 4-0 Respectfully -- Submitted, Andrew Grimes, Secretary Page 16 NOBLI, ad-Fwd: Online Fam Submittal: Board ofLibrary .GtV .. about'. blank Lannon, Amy <lannon@nobtenetorg> Fwd: Online Form Submittal: Board of Library Trustees - Contact Us 2 messages Trustee, Reading <mlfmstee@nobkmet DM> Mon. Sep S. 2025 at 6 54 AM To Amy Lannon <lannon@noblenel crg> --- Forwarded message --- From. norepy@civicplus.com <nomply@civicylus corn, Data: Sat, Sep 6, 2025 at 4.08 PM Subject: Online Form Submittal: Board of Library Trustees - Contact Us To: <rpltruwee@noblenatorq> Board of Library Trustees - Contact Us Board of Library Trustees Patrick Egan Stuff Furst Name Alison Your E-mail Address allisonsban321@grnilcom SrLled _�—_-- MLTA request Message Patrick, let me Introduce myself, as a 30-year former RPL employee (mostly Technical Services and ILL), I'm mow a lDmry trustee at Flint Library in MiMelon. I'm also the current President of the Massachusetts Ubwy Trustee Associaam Ut� 1 �'` Y\ (MLTA), an that's the hat I'm wearing today to ask you and the RPL Board's to i+e rfA .1 O I lh partbi ate. Lt �yt;� P I'm asking the RPL Trustees N they will join MLTA inflow year for the enure Board. FM the membership firm on Co,F> `41 themltaorg website. MLTA Board meets monthly on Zoom for an hour. We are asking trustees to attend our meetings and help as we support library trustees around the state. Also to Invite you all to attend our annual conference on Nov,. tat from 10sm-2pm at Shrewsbury library, free registration and lunch' "Communication and Advocacy" is the theme, and our speaker will present the "Building Bridges" program that was a log hit at the MIA Conference last May. It fiibws the ideas of Legislative Breakfasts and working with state officials to support library causes. I hope to hear back from you, and happy to provide more information. We work closely wfth MBLC and MLA, and looking to develop partnerships viih other library rings. Allison ,.., Allison Sloan e!A/9e14 R-SO AM RMLD Quick Update We've put together the charging session data for year to date in 2025 compared to 2024. We do see a drop in level charging after that parking spot was painted black. It could be possible that some of this might be partially caused by higher usage last year with the fast charging station outage, but we are not sure at this point. Fast charging continues to grow, and we'd definitely want to keep this trend. Reading Library Level Chargiri of Sessions 100 90 so 10 so 50 40 00 10 20 len Feb Mar Apr - ice, lea ■ 2024 a 2025 Reading Library Fast Charging M of Sessions 250 200 150 100 ' ' 0 lan Feb 11.11 Ma. Apr May a 2024 a 2025 i u FALL 2025 Public Services Update SUMMER READING RECAP HING OUT Adult Summer Reading: Summer of Story SILENT READING ►ARTIESI July V, 2:30-4:30pm BIG, Mao July 23. 6-9pm C..", out August 9. 12-2pm L..n L.0 11n8 TEEN RUMMER READING 202E FOR TEENS ENTERING GRADES 6-12 //` `•\ June 16-August 23 i m RAW ING OVT OWN YOUR VOICE WRITING WORKSHOP JW y 9, 6 10-e.10 vv. STORYTELLING E PURLIC SPEAKING July 29.1-8 PM August 12, i-g PM READING VOICES, TELL ..mum YOUR STORY LIVEI Z% CMMM= N e� August 23.12-3 PM pO 20 ® LAW fa f CHILDREN'S SR SURVEY Compared to previous summer reading programs, how much did you like this one? ]o responses 1 liked this one more than previous summer reading programs. 1 liked Ibis one less than previous summer reading programs. s We've never done a summer readna program be/ore. CHILDREN'S SR SURVEY In your opinion, what do you think is the most important part of summer reading at the library? 20 responses 0 Help with the summer slide • Sociallzirplmaking new hieMs Promoting reading as a fun activity • Making the library a part of your routine Daughter says It's fuel! LECTURES & WORKSHOP HIGHLIGHTS • Braver Angels: Learning to Disagree Better in Polarizing Titms 1 • Pickle making, tea, and coffee tastings • Children's Halloween Costume Swap • When Johnny Comes Marching Home - The Death and Life of Larry Benson • George Washington and the Creation of the American Republic with Bill Fowler • Korean Myths with Authors Jihyun Yon and Ryan Estrada • Storytime with Coats! '0� NP MAHJONGG MANIA n SERIES • Mortality 101 • Toddler Yoga • Mahjongg • Act it Out Storybook Theater • Start up Squad & Shark Tank jr: entrepreneur classes for kids NEW & RENEWED COne on One Tech Help Appointments 2 ! Teen Book Group & Reading Rocket tween/parent book group .3 Family Concert Series: Little Groove, Marian Iranzi, Mara & Motoko, Rockabye Beats, Sulinha's Trio & Peter Sheridan 'a Connected Reading: An Open House for Our Community Partnering with Public Health: CPR Classes, Flu Clinic, Blood Pressure & Hearing Screenings MEET UPS Board Game Teen Talks 2• Nights 4• with Liv �• Crochet & Knit Drop In f 3• Between Time S. pokemon Club l� THANK YOU State of the collection — September 2025 Circulation of physical items is trending downward a bit in most libraries over the past 3 years. However, ebook and eaudio are trending upward. FY25 Reading is highest circulating individual library in NOBLE (Beverly system is higher, but that includes 3 branches. The main branch is 2ntl after Reading. Reading is 4' in Overdrive circulation 8" highest number of patrons 3 colleges higher than RDG, municipalities with higher # are Beverly, Lynn, Peabody, and Salem Digital Resources Update The cuts to the Federal Institute of Museum and Library Services resulted in cuts in the digital resources provided by the Commonwealth. After reviewing the usage statistics and evaluating our other offerings, we determined it was most important to maintain digital access to the Boston Globe and added it to our budget for FY26. We reviewed usage and in particular cost per use of all of the databases and decided to cancel Financial Fit and Home Improvement Source. Another cost -saving measure is a reduction in the allowed 'borrows' per month in the Hoopla collection, from 12 to 9. We will be promoting Craft & Hobby, added last year, to we if we can raise its numbers this year. Library of Things The combination of our new catalog, new website, and new storage cabinets prompted a review of the catalog records for all the items in the LOT collection. We worked with the Borrowers Services staff to rename and add search terms to the records, making it easier to find and place holds on the various items. Going forward, we will work on the "Go and Grow" collection in the Children's Room. Show photos of cabinets in Google Drive Lockers Our lockers went live in November 2022. The reporting from the software was difficult and it was hard to tell how many transactions we had. In May of 2024, Valerie worked with NOBLE to report circulation from each work station, including the lockers so now we now how many checkouts occurred from the lockers Locker circulation Time Period Items placed in Lockers Ma -24 14 Jun-24 25 Jul-24 77 Au -24 77 Sep-24 72 Oct-24 so Nov-24 36 Dec-24 46 Jan-25 69 Feb-25 40 Mar-25 106 54 A 65 63 73 Average 6o -Lockers out of commission for 7 days Aspen Catalog Interface Beginning this month, users will see a new screen when they search the catalog. It provides search assistance, integrates our ebook and eaudiobook collections, (allowing users to check out a Libby title, for example, without leaving the catalog), and groups formats and editions of a title together, making it easier to find the format you need. We will also be able to highlight local collections and events —for instance, a search for an author can bring up a notice of an upcoming author visit along with the book results. The new catalog interface will go live before the end of September. From RPL website, search for Remarkably bright creatures, Then switch to Aspen Reading Circulation By Ans (FY2025) - Adult YA _. _._--- _--__- Child Total Fir W25 6710 9 3,458 . 30,1)] Total Circulation :330,916 _ 99,796 11,719 175,400 286,915 CM1eckouts. 174,927 ties 1,301 162 245 1,751 Staff Renewals: 3,432 museum passes 912 1 1,950 2,863 quto-Renewal,'. 144540 alz 6,620 33 723 ],3]6 Web Renewals. 8,O1J 16.836 ]d 4,134 20,986 _ Holds filled. 3d,298 132,218 11,938 185,910 330,0616 Reading Circulation By Ant IFY2024) FY 2024 na[ Adult YA Child Total Total Circulation: 342,051 0 8,323 27 3,912 12,162 Checkouts : 184,994 11 101,022 13,4% 179,070 293,582 Staff Renewals'. 3,084 ogames 998 185 286 1,469 Auto Renewals: 138,599 and museum passes 688 0 1,626 2,334 _Web Renewals: 15,375 :Serials 7,239 E4 Shc ],BId Holds Filled: 35,699 0 18,J01 16 d,1J9 22,8% AL9 -. 136,9)1 13,782 189,514 300,267 _. Reading Circulation By Ans IFY2023) FY 2023 _. sat Adult YA Child Total _.. Total Circulation:3d9,0]d o 7,684 27 3,907 11,618 - - Checkouts : 393,453 rs 302,282 14,086 182,270 298,638 Staff Renewals. 3,862 blames 968 162 496 1,626 Auto Renewals: 132,956 and museum passes 639 1 953 1.593� Web Renewals: 18,803 :Serials 4,227 32 372 4,631 Holds Filled: 37,149 0 19,595 22 5,778 25,395 - - ALS 235,395 14,330 193,))6 343,501 Reading Overdrive Circulation (FY2025) Category eBook Audiobook Total Adult Fiction 18,307 16,145 34, Adult Nonfiction 3,752 4,614 8, Children Fiction 5,990 2,563 8, Children Nonfiction 692 134 Young Adult Fiction 1,846 1,588 3, Young Adult Nonfiction 107 61 TOTALS 30,694 25,105 55, Reading Overdrive Circulation (FY2024) :ategory eBook Audiobook Total Ault Fiction 17,491 13,681 31,172 adult Nonfiction 4,174 4,680 8,854 :hildren Fiction 5,510 2,589 8,099 :hildren Nonfiction 445 112 557 oung Adult Fiction 1,814 1,612 3,426 oung Adult Nonfiction 140 45 185 'OTALS 29,574 22,729 52,293 Reading Overdrive Circulation (FY2023) :ategory eBook Audiobook Total idult Fiction 7,952 5,166 13,1 kdult Nonfiction 2,421 2,215 4,1 :hildren Fiction 12,342 7,785 20,1 :hildren Nonfiction 1,944 1,524 3,4 oung Adult Fiction 1,708 1,345 3,( oung Adult Nonfiction 104 46 1 Locker circulation Time Period Items placed in Lockers May-24 14 Jun-24 25 Jul-24 77 Aug-24 77 Sep-24 72 Oct-24 80 Nov-24 36 Dec-24 46 Jan-25 69 Feb-25 40 Mar-25 108 Apr-25 54 May-25 65 Jun-25 63 Jul-25 73 Average 60 -Lockers out of commission for days library of things 7rme Period Circulation Jul-24 52 Aug-24 62 Sep-24 43 Oct-24 49 Nov-24 38 Dec-24 55 Jan-25 47 Feb-25 46 Mar-25 40 Apr-25 49 Ma -25 45 Jun-25 S2