Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout2025-03-19 Finance Committee Packet Town of Reading Meeting Posting with Agenda 2018-07-16LAG Board -Committee -Commission -Council: Finance Committee Date: 2025-03-19Time: 7:00PM Building: Reading Town Hall Location: Select Board Meeting Room Address: 16 Lowell StreetAgenda: Purpose:General Business Meeting Called By:Jacquelyn LaVerde on behalf of Chair Joe Carnahan Notices and agendas are to be posted 48 hours in advance of the meetings excluding operation and make necessary arrangements to be sure your posting is made in an adequate amount of time. A listing of topics that the chair reasonably anticipates will be discussed at the meeting must be on the agenda. All Meeting Postings must be submitted in typed format; handwritten notices will notbe accepted. Topics of Discussion: This meeting will be held in-person in the Town Hall Select Board Meeting Room and remotely via Zoom: Join Zoom Meeting https://us06web.zoom.us/j/84126347693 Meeting ID: 841 2634 7693 Dial by your location Find your local number: https://us06web.zoom.us/u/kd93oH65O AGENDA: Call to Order and Welcome Public Comment Liaison Reports Discuss and Vote on FY26 Budget Discuss and Vote on other financial articles for 2025 Annual Town Meeting Discuss Finance Committee Report to Town Meeting Future Agendas Approve Prior Meeting Minutes This Agenda has been prepared in advance and represents a listing of topics that the chair reasonably anticipates will be discussed at the meeting. However the agenda does not necessarily include all matters which may be taken up at this meeting. Page | 1 FY26 Spending Scorecard LineCategory %FY26 Budget FY26 Budget % FY25 Budget Grand Town Finance %Grand revisedTotalManagerCommitteechngTotal 15.7%10.9%16.8% $22,350,282 $24,790,102 B99Benefits$24,790,102 2.7%-10.3%2.3% $3,787,000 $3,398,000 C99Capital$3,398,000 2.9%-25.5%2.1% $4,097,738 $3,051,975 D99Debt service$3,051,975 0.8%18.6%0.9% $1,110,992 $1,317,435 E99Education - Vocational$1,317,435 0.1%0.0%0.1% $200,000 $200,000 F99Finance Committee Reserves$200,000 22.1%3.8%22.2% Total Shared Costs $ 31,546,012 $ 32,757,512 $ 32,757,512 0.9%-1.7%0.9% $1,288,100 $1,266,300 G91Administrative Svcs wages$1,266,300 1.2%0.0%1.1% $1,684,700 $1,685,468 G92Administrative Svcs expenses$1,685,468 0.4%3.3%0.4% $521,800 $539,100 G91aTechnology wages$539,100 0.5%11.7%0.5% $679,700 $759,300 G92aTechnology expenses$759,300 1.0%4.1%1.0% $1,472,184 $1,532,034 H91Public Services wages$1,532,034 0.2%0.6%0.2% $312,100 $313,928 H92Public Services expenses$313,928 0.7%5.5%0.8% $1,065,500 $1,123,600 I91Finance wages$1,123,600 0.1%-12.2%0.1% $172,650 $151,600 I92Finance expenses$151,600 9.7%3.1%9.7% $13,851,471 $14,277,839 J91Public Safety wages$14,277,839 0.5%9.3%0.5% $724,946 $792,208 J92Public Safety expenses$792,208 2.3%4.8%2.3% $3,219,700 $3,375,650 K91Public Works wages$3,375,650 0.8%-10.1%0.7% $1,165,400 $1,048,135 K92Public Works expenses$1,048,135 0.5%0.0%0.5% $675,000 $675,000 K93Public Works Snow & Ice$675,000 0.1%0.0%0.1% $135,000 $135,000 K94Public Works Street Lights$135,000 1.5%2.7%1.5% $2,141,278 $2,200,041 K95Public Works Rubbish$2,200,041 1.2%3.2%1.2% $1,754,250 $1,810,050 L91Library wages$1,810,050 0.3%5.4%0.3% $426,900 $450,000 L92Library expenses$450,000 2.8%3.4%2.8% $3,938,760 $4,072,432 M91Core Facilities$4,072,432 0.3%3.0%0.3% $378,450 $389,936 M92Town Buildings$389,936 25.0%2.8%24.8% Total Municipal Gov't $ 35,607,889 $ 36,597,621 $ 36,597,621 39.5%3.9%39.7% U99School Department$56,310,811 $58,491,591 $58,491,591 86.6%3.5% $ 123,464,712 $ 127,846,724 $ 127,846,724 VOTED GENERAL FUND $ 930,7390.7%$ 954,0072.5%0.6% State Assessments $ 954,007 87.3%3.5% TOTAL $ 124,395,451 $ 128,800,731 $ 128,800,731 5.5%11.7%5.9% $7,771,629 $8,683,575 W99Water Enterprise Fund$8,683,575 6.1%-0.3%5.9% $8,762,366 $8,734,796 X99Sewer Enterprise Fund$8,734,796 0.7%-43.2%0.4% $1,024,625 $581,625 Y99Storm Water Enterprise Fund$581,625 0.4%-3.7%0.4% $539,000 $519,000 Z99PEG Access Enterprise Fund$519,000 0.0%0.0%0.0% $37,000 $37,000 ZZ9Landfill Enterprise Fund$37,000 $18,134,62012.7%$18,555,996$18,555,9962.3%12.6% TOTAL ENTERPRISE FUNDS $141,599,33299.3%$146,402,720$ 146,402,72099.4% GRAND TOTAL VOTED3.4% 2 COMMONWEALTH OF MASSACHUSETTS Middlesex, ss. Officer's Return, Town of Reading: By virtue of this Warrant, I ______________________________, on ____________, 2025 notified and warned the inhabitants of the Town of Reading, qualified to vote on Town affairs, to meet at the place and at the time specified by posting attested copies of this Town Meeting Warrant, in the following public places within the Town of Reading: Precinct 1J. Warren Killam School, 333 Charles Street Precinct 2 Reading Police Station, 15 Union Street Precinct 3Reading Municipal Light Department, 230 Ash Street Precinct 4Joshua Eaton School, 365 Summer Avenue Precinct 5Reading Public Library, 64 Middlesex Avenue Precinct 6Barrows School, 16 Edgemont Avenue Precinct 7Birch Meadow School, 27 Arthur B Lord Drive Precinct 8Wood End School, 85 Sunset Rock Lane Town Hall, 16 Lowell Street The date of posting being not less than fourteen (14) days prior to April 8, 2025, the date set for Town Meeting in this Warrant. _____________________________________________ Constable A true copy Attest: _____________________________________________ Laura Gemme, Town Clerk TOWN WARRANT COMMONWEALTH OF MASSACHUSETTS Middlesex, ss. To any of the Constables of the Town of Reading, Greetings: In the name of the Commonwealth of Massachusetts, you are hereby required to notify and warn the inhabitants of the Town of Reading, qualified to vote in the Local Elections and Town affairs, to meet in the following place designated for the eight precincts in said Town, namely: Precincts 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7 and 8 Reading Memorial High School, Hawkes Field House, Oakland Road TUESDAY, the EIGHTH DAY OF APRIL, A.D., 2025 from 7:00 a.m. to 8:00 p.m. to act on the following Articles, viz: ARTICLE 1 To elect by ballot the following Town Officers: A Moderator for one year; Two members of the Board of Selectmen for three years; Two members of the Board of Library Trustees for three years; Two members of the Municipal Light Board for three years; Two members of the School Committee for three years; Sixty-five Town Meeting Members shall be elected to represent each of the following precincts: Precinct 1 Eight members for three years; Precinct 2 Eight members for three years; Precinct 3 Eight members for three years; Precinct 3 One member for one year; Precinct 4 Eight members for three years; Precinct 5 Eight members for three years; Precinct 6 Eight members for three years; Precinct 7 Eight members for three years; and Precinct 8 Eight members for three years and to meet at the Reading Memorial High School, 62 Oakland Road, in said Reading on MONDAY, the TWENTY-EIGHTH DAY of APRIL A.D., 2025 at seven-thirty upon and determined exclusively by Town Meeting Members in accordance with the provisions of the Reading Home Rule Charter. ARTICLE 2To hear and act on the reports of the SelectBoard, School Committee, Library Trustees, Municipal Light Board, Finance Committee, Bylaw Committee, Town Manager, Town Accountant and any other Town Official, Board or Committee. Select Board ARTICLE 3To choose all other necessary Town Officers and Boards or Committees and determine what instructions shall be given to Town Officers and Boards or Committees, and to see what sum the Town will vote to appropriate by borrowing or transfer from available funds, or otherwise, for the purpose of funding Town Officers and Boards or Committees to carry out the instructions givento them, or take any other action with respect thereto. Select Board ARTICLE 4To see if the Town will vote to amend the FY 2025-35Capital Improvements Program as provided for in Section 7-7 of the Reading Home Rule Charter and as previously amended,or take any other action with respect thereto. Select Board Background:This Article is included in every Town Meeting Warrant. The Reading General Bylaw (section 6.1.3) states item is included in the Capital Improvements Programand is scheduled for funding in the Fiscal Year in which the appropriation is to be made."Bond ratingagencies also want to adequately describe changes to a long-term Capital Improvements Program (CIP). The following changes are proposed to the FY2025FY2035CIP (current year plus ten years): General Fund FY25: +$143,000 net change $ 50,000 Salemand Main Street Traffic Signal Improvements $ 33,000 Vehicle Lift Replacement $ 60,000 Firewall Upgrade FY26: +$386,000 netchange $150,000 Design for Artificial Turf at Parker MS $100,000Salem Street Crosswalk Improvements $ 25,000 Engineering Plotter $113,000 Increase Roadpaving FY27: +$23,000 net change $200,000 Facilities Master Plan $283,000 Main St Fire StationElevator Replacement -$ 85,000 BM Food Service Line (will be paid by school lunch revolving fund) -$ 85,000 Barrows Food Service Line (will be paid by school lunch revolving fund) -$52,000 Food Service Van (will be paid by school lunch revolving fund) -$120,000 Cemetery Dump Truck out 2 years -$120,000 Highway Dump Truck out 1 yr $ 50,000 Forest Street Crosswalk Improvement Design Work -$275,000 Sander Truck out 1 yr $181,000 Increase Road Paving Enterprise Funds Water FY25: +$0 FY26: +$0 FY27: +$0 Enterprise Funds Sewer FY25: +$0 FY26: +$0 FY27: +$0 Enterprise Funds Storm Water FY25: +$0 FY26: +$0 FY27: +$0 Finance Committee Report:The Finance Committee recommends the proposed amendments to the FY 2025 FY 2035 Capital Improvements Program by a vote of X-X at their meeting on March X, 2025. Placing items in the Capital Improvement Program is a prerequisite first step but in itself does not authorize spending funds toward these items. Bylaw Committee Report:No Report. ARTICLE 5 Fiscal Year commencing July 1, 2024, as adopted under Article 12of the Annual Town Meeting of April 25, 2024and amended under Article 4 of the Subsequent Town Meeting ofNovember 12, 2024; and to see if the Town will vote to raise and appropriate, borrow or transfer from available funds, or otherwise provide a sum or sums of money to be added to the amounts appropriated under said Article, as amended, for the operation of the Town and its government, or take any other action with respect thereto. Finance Committee Background: Account LineDescriptionDecreaseIncrease B99 Benefits Health Insurance +$200,000 $334,000 Unemployment +$ 30,000 Disability retirementsalary movedto benefits +$104,000 C-99-CapitalSee Article 4$143,000 F99-FINCOM Election Workers/Expense$60,000$80,000 ReservesTraffic Signal Repairs $20,000 E99 Minuteman Regional -$45,000$45,000 Regional Vocational Education H91 Public Attrition Savings$75,000 Services Wages H92-Public $50,000 Services Expense I91 Finance Open-position savings $40,000 Wages I92 Finance Assessing Bridge to MUNIS for Hero Exemptions$6,000 Expense J91 Public Fire Retirements -Vacation Buyouts $100,000$125,000 Safety WagesFire Overtime $25,000 J92 Public Health -Rodent Control$35,000 Safety Expenses K91 Public Attrition savings$75,000 Works Wages K-93 Snow & Snow & Ice Expenses$275,000 Ice K-94 Street StreetLightExpenses-$25,000 $25,000 Lights Subtotals$310,000958,000 Net Operating Expenses$688,000 From Free Cash$688,000 Finance Committee Report:At their meeting on March X, 2025, the Finance Committee voted X-X to recommend Article 5 to Town Meeting. Bylaw Committee Report:No Report. ARTICLE 6To see if the Town will vote to raise and appropriate, transfer from available funds, borrow or otherwise provide a sum or sums of money to pay bills remaining unpaid from prior fiscal years for goods and services actually rendered to the Town, or take anyother action with respect thereto. Select Board Background:There are no prior years'bills;this Article is expected to be tabled. Finance Committee Report:No Report. (if tabled) Bylaw Committee Report:No Report. ARTICLE 7To see if the Town will vote to raise and appropriate, transfer from available funds, borrow or otherwise provide a sum or sums of money for the purpose of funding the -,or take any other action with respect thereto. Select Board Background:Each year at the Annual Town Meeting, we ask to transfer funds budgeted for OPEB from that line to the actual OPEB Trust in this Article. Sometimes, due to budget surpluses in health insurance premiums, we have increased the budgeted contribution figures; we are also prepared to ask to lower the budgeted contribution figures to cover health insurance premium deficits. Recent contributions to the Trust on behalf of the General Fund have been $300,000 (FY24) and 500,000(FY23). This year, the TownMeeting is requested to make the annual transfers of funds previously budgeted and held for the OPEB Trust Fund. This practice is followed yearlyifhealth insurance costs are higher than budgetedandmay be needed to fund a deficit. In FY25, the budgeted transfers are $200,000 for the general fund,$85,000 for the water fund, $25,000 for the sewer fund, and $10,500 forthe stormwaterfund. This articlewill, therefore,move the total $320,500of all these OPEB contributions to the trust for Other Post Employment Benefit liabilities. The most recent OPEB valuation shows the Town's OPEB liability at $59.9millionand13.84% fundedas of June 30, 2024.The three Enterprise Funds and the Light Department are on afull funding schedule, and the General Fund is on a partial funding schedule. As noted, the General Fund will transition to a full funding schedule as soon as possible, as is required by law,or immediately after the Pension Fund is fully funded. Finance Committee Report:At their meeting on March X, 2025, the Finance Committee voted X-X to recommend Article 7 to Town Meeting. Bylaw Committee Report:No Report. ARTICLE 8To see if the Town will vote to(1)establish the limit on the total amount that may be expended from each revolving fund established by Article 6of the Town of Reading General Bylaw pursuant to Section 53E½ of Chapter 44 of the Massachusetts General Lawsfor the fiscal year beginning July 1, 2025; (2) amend Section 6.5.2 of the General Bylaw, establishing the Inspection Revolving Fund, as shown below, with the deletions being struck through and additions being in bold; 6.5.2 Inspection Revolving Fund Funds held in the Inspection Revolving Fund shall be used for legal costs, oversight and inspection, plan review, property appraisals and appeals, public services general management, pedestrian safety improvements, records archiving, and other costs related to building, plumbing, wiring, gas, and other permits required for large construction projects and shall be expended by the Town Manager. Receipts credited to this fund shall include building, plumbing, wiring, gas and other permit fees for Johnson Woods, Eaton Lakeview (23-25 Lakeview Avenue and 128 Eaton Street), 258 Main Street, 6-16 Chute Street (Green Tomato), 25 Haven Street (Rite Aid), Main Street (Chase Bank),346-348 Main Street,and 459 Main Street (128 Tire) developments. And (3) establish a new Elder and Human Services Revolving Fund pursuant to Section 53E½ of Chapter 44 of the Massachusetts General Laws, effective July 1, 2025, by taking the following actions: (a) adding a new Section 6.5.8 to the General Bylaws to read as follows: 6.5.8 Elder and Human Services Revolving Fund Funds held in the Elder and Human Services Revolving Fund shall be used for Elder and Human Services programming, including the acquisition of materials and equipment for such programming, and shall be expended by the Elder and Human Services Administrator. Receipts creditedto this fund shall include user and rental fees from the Elder and Human Services programming. and (b) establishingthe limit on the total amount that may be expended from the new Elder and Human Services Revolving Fundpursuant to Section 53E½ of Chapter 44 of the Massachusetts General Lawsfor the fiscal year beginning July 1, 2025. Or take any other action with respect thereto. Select Board Background: RevolvingSpendingRevenueAllowedExpend-Year End AccountAuthoritySourceExpensesitureBalance Limits Conservation Conservation Fees as provided for Consulting and $25,000Available for Commission Commissionin Reading General engineering services expenditure Consulting Bylaws Section 5.7, for the review of next year FeesWetlands Protectiondesigns and engineering work for the protection of wetlands. Inspection Town Building, Plumbing, Legal, oversight and $250,000Available for Revolving ManagerWiring, Gas and other inspection, plan expenditure Fundpermits for the review, initial property next year projects listed in the appraisals and Article.appeals, Public Services planning and general management, curb, sidewalks and pedestrian safety improvements, records archiving and other project related costs. Public Health Board of Clinic fees, charges Materials and costs $25,000Available for Clinics and Healthand third-party associated with expenditure Servicesreimbursementsclinics and public next year health programs Library Library Charges for lost or Acquire Library $15,000Available for Fines and Director and damaged Library materials to replace expenditure Fees Trusteesmaterialslost or damaged next year and fees from printing, items, and for the faxing or similar maintenance, upkeep supplementary fee-and supplies for based services.supplementary fee- based services Mattera Facilities Rental FeesUtilities and all other $10,000Available for Cabin Director maintenance and expenditure Operating operating expensesnext year Community Conservation Rental and user feesUtilities and all other $10,000Available for Gardens at Administrator maintenance and expenditure Mattera operating expenses, next year Cabinand project supplies and equipment Solid Waste Director of Lease of second Offset the cost of $250,000Available for Revolving Public Worksbarrels and overflow curbside trash & expenditure Fundupon the bags,recycling collection, next year recommendadisposal of solid tion of the waste, replacement Town toters, and any other Managercosts associated with the administration of the trash and recycling program Elder and Elder and Elder and Human User and rental fees $15,000Available for Human Human Services from the Elder and expenditure Services Servicesprogramming, Human Services next year Revolving Administratorincluding acquiringprogramming Fundmaterials and equipment. Town ForestDirector of Sale of timber; fees for Planning and $10,000Available for Public Works use of the Town Improvements to the expenditure upon the ForestTown Forestnext year recommenda tion of the Town Forest Committee Conservation Consulting Revolving Fund-These funds are used to receive payments from applicants, hire expert consultants where required, and return the balance to the applicant. The balance in this Fund as of March 2025is $33,257. Inspections Revolving FundThe balance available as of March 2025in this fund is $769,976,and of that total,$183,700is proposed by the Town Manager as part of the FY25 budget {$133,700to support General Admin and Economic Development wages and expenses; and $50,000 to offset Building Inspections division wages}. Health Clinic Revolving Fund-The Reading Health Division contracts for third-party payments for severalimmunizations.The funds augment the influenza vaccine supply from the State Department of Public Health to ensure vaccines for homebound clients and first responders. The division also uses these funds to providematerials for other screening clinics.Clinic client fees are also deposited into this fund to offset vaccine and clinical supply costs. The balance available as of March 2025in this fund is $12,553.The State has been cutting back on the free flu and other vaccines to be distributed to citiesand towns, and the Town needs to purchase extra doses. The necessary amounts used for clinic vaccines, supplies, and staff salaries related to the clinics each year directly from the revolving fund is approximately $25,000. Library Fines and Fees FundAcquire Library materials to replace lost or damaged items and for maintenance, upkeep, and supplies for supplementary fee-basedservices. The balance available as of March 2025in this fund is $11,277.16. Mattera CabinOperating FundSome of the Cabin's uses generate revenue, and this Article allows those revenues to be used directly for the cabin's operating expenses. The balance available as of March 2025in this fund is $0. Community Gardens at Mattera CabinOperating FundThis fund was created at Annual Town Meeting in April 2022. This revolving fund providesa mechanism for the Conservation Commission to generate revenue (e.g., fees from the gardeners) and expend it on utilities, other maintenance as well as operating expenses, equipment, and supplies.The Community Garden continues to grow and attract regional support. The balance available as of March 2025in this fund is $2,692. Solid Waste Revolving Fundwas created in 2023. The purpose is to offsetthe cost of curbside trash andrecycling collection, disposal of solid waste, replacement toters, and any other costs associated with the administration of the trash and recycling program. The balance available as of March 2025in this fund is $1,224. Elder and Human Services Revolving Fundwas created in 2025. This new fund allows user fees for Elder and Human Services programming to be used to pay for programming and related supplies and equipment. The balance available as of March 2025in this fund is $0. Town Forest Revolving Fundwas created in 2011. The purpose is to allow revenues from controlled timber harvesting and permit fees to then be spent by the DPW Director onthe recommendation of the Town Forest Committee, on improvements to the Town Forest. The Town Forest Committee has had a forest stewardship plan created (through a grant) to make recommendations on forest management including controlled timber harvesting.The balance available as of March 2025in this fund is $0. Finance Committee Report:At their meeting on March X, 2025, the Finance Committee voted X-X to recommend Article 8 to Town Meeting. Bylaw Committee Report:At their meeting on March X, 2025, the Bylaw Committee voted X-X to recommend Article 8 to Town Meeting. ARTICLE 9To see if the Town will vote to accept G.L. c. 59, § 5, clause 22I, which authorizes an annual increase in the amount of the exemption granted to certain veterans under G.L. c. 59, § 5, clauses 22, 22A, 22B, 22C, 22E, and 22F by the percentage increase in the U.S. Department of Labor, Bureau of Labor Statistics, Consumer Price Index for the previous year as determined by the Commissioner of Revenue, to be effective for applicable exemptions granted for any fiscal year beginning on or after July 1, 2025; or to take any other action with respect thereto. Select Board Background: recently passed Act Honoring, Empowering and Recognizing Our Servicemembers and Veterans Clause 22I, if accepted, would increase the amount of certain tax exemption granted to veterans on their domiciles by a cost-of-living adjustment (COLA) determined by the Department of Revenue (DOR) based on the consumer price index (CPI). This would work like the annual COLA adjustment determined by DOR that is already a local option for certain senior exemption amounts and financial means standards. For example, if a Clause 22 recipient will receive a $400 exemption and the community accepts this option, and the CPI increases by 5%, the total exemption amount would increase to $420. Finance Committee Report:At their meeting on March X, 2025, the Finance Committee voted X-X to recommend Article 9 to Town Meeting. Bylaw Committee Report:At their meeting on March X, 2025, the Bylaw Committee voted X-X to recommend Article 9 to Town Meeting. ARTICLE10To see if the Town will vote to accept G.L. c. 59, § 5, clause 22J, which authorizes an annual increase in the amount of the exemption granted under G.L. c. 59, § 5, clauses 22, 22A, 22B, 22C, 22E, and 22F by 100% of the personal exemption amount, subject to the conditions in Clause 22J, to be effective for applicable exemptions granted for any fiscal year beginning on or after July 1, 2025; or to take any other action with respectthereto. Select Board Background:Clause 22J, if accepted, provides an additional exemption up to 100% of the amount of the tax exemption granted to veterans on their domiciles under Clause 22, Clause 22A, Clause 22B, Clause 22C, Clause 22E and Clause 22F. This would work like the optionaladditional exemption that is already a local option under G.L. c. 59, § 5C½ for all persons granted exemptions on their domiciles as veterans, seniors, blind persons, and surviving spouses. Clause 22J will not apply in a yearin which the town already uses G.L. c. 59, § 5C½ to grant an additional exemption to all persons granted exemptions. It is an option for towns that do not use that general additional exemption to be able to just grant one for persons granted veteran exemptions. As with the general additional exemption, the application of the Clause 22J additional exemption cannot reduce the tax owed below what the taxpayer would owe on 10% of the current assessed valuation of the domicile. However, unlike the general additional exemption, the exemption granted to veterans can result in the taxpayer paying less than the taxes paid in the preceding fiscal year. To implement, town must vote to accept the statute and establish the additional exemption percentage before the July1 beginning of the fiscal year in which that percentage will first apply. The voted percentage will continue to apply in subsequent years unless and until another percentage is voted before the July 1 beginning of a later fiscal year. Finance Committee Report:At their meeting on March X, 2025, the Finance Committee voted X-X to recommend Article 10 to Town Meeting. Bylaw Committee Report:At their meeting on March X, 2025, the Bylaw Committee voted X-X to recommend Article 10 to Town Meeting. ARTICLE 11To see if the Town will vote to raise and appropriate, transfer from available funds, borrow or otherwise provide a sum or sums of moneyfor the operation of the Town and its government for Fiscal Year 2026,beginning July 1, 2025, or take any other action with respect thereto. Finance Committee Background:Please see the Budget pages followingthis Warrant Report, which include full details of theFY26Finance Committee budget. Finance Committee Report:Please see the FY26 Spending Scorecard for the votes of the Finance Committee on line items in the FY26 budget. The Finance Committee recommends the subject matter of Article 11 as explained by these votes at their meeting on March X, 2025. Bylaw Committee Report:No Report. ARTICLE 12To see if the Town will vote to authorize the Select Board to acquire by purchase, gift, eminent domain or otherwise, for general municipal purposes, a portion of 170 Ash totaling approximately 261 square feet, and LLC, 413 Main Street, Lot 64 & 85, Map 17, Town of Reading, Middlesex County, Commonwealth Point Associates, Inc, which pla office, on such terms and conditions as the Select Board deems proper, or take any other action related thereto. Select Board Background:The Town is set to agree with the property owner of 413 Main Street (Assessors Map 17, Lots 64 and 85), 413 Main Street LLC,to accept a parcel of land shownas Parcel Aon the USA, LLC, 413 Main Street, Town of Reading, Middlesex County, Commonwealth of Massachusetts, prepared by Control Point Associated,dated March 12, 2024. The property underwent redevelopment for the re-construction of the pre-existing fast- food restaurant with drive-through use in 2023-24. During the plan review process and initial survey it was found that a portion of the Town sidewalk along Bolton Street was within the private property boundary of 413 Main Street. The associated parcel to be accepted by the Town will correct the property bounds so that the sidewalk is fully within Town control and right-of-way limits. It totals 261sf of area. If approved the Town will accept the parcel as-is. Finance Committee Report:No Report. Bylaw Committee Report:No Report. ARTICLE 13To see if the Town will vote to raise and appropriate, transfer from available funds or otherwise provide a sum or sums of money to pay the costs ofinfrastructure improvements to the High Street and Haven Street Infrastructure Project, including replacement of roadway, sidewalks, and related improvements, including the payment of any and all other costs incidental and related thereto,said sum to be expended under the direction of the Town Manager; and, for the purpose of meeting such appropriation, authorize the Town Treasurer, with the approval of the Select Board, to allocatesaid sum in accordance with G.L. c. 44, §7(1), or any other enabling authority,or take any other action with respect thereto. Select Board Background:Since the onset of the Downtown Smart Growth District, the downtown has welcomed multiple redevelopment projects. One area where the Town has seen significant development has been along Haven Street. In order to accommodate this growth, the Town has invested in an extensive utility improvement plan. Additionally, the need has risen to revitalize and improve the lower Haven St and High Street streetscape for better access for both vehicles and pedestrians. The goal would also be to activate the street to help improve safety, economic growth and activity through improved right of way infrastructure/design (bump-outs, shorter crossings, etc.), lighting, landscape, and other amenities to support local visitors, businesses, and programs. The project would focus on Haven Street (Gould St. to High St.) and High Street (Washington St. Woburn St.) corridors. The area corresponds with the green designated area in the image below. In 2019, the Town hired Beta Group, Inc. to develop a 25% conceptual plan for Haven Street. This conceptual plan included a full topographic survey, traffic analysis, and the 25% design. Beta Group was instrumental in the Main Street improvements and was asked to extend their design and input from Main Street to the Haven Street corridor. During the initial phase of the design, staff input was compiled and incorporated into a functioning conceptual plan. At the November 2022 SubsequentTown Meeting, members voted to approve $750,000 in design funds. Subsequently, Beta Group was tasked with finalizing the design and bid documents in addition to assisting the Town in pursuit of a Mass Works grant. In September 2023, the State awarded Reading $2.6 million from the Mass Works Infrastructure Program to support construction of this Project. In 2024, Beta Group provided a revised engineering budget which estimated the reconstruction of Haven and High Street corridors to be approximately $4M. Beta Group also extended costs for the adjacent streets and the Town owned Upper Haven parking lot for future phases considerations. To support the projects total cost the Town will be looking to allocate unexpended funds from various accounts and previously completed projects to help supplement the overall project cost. These funds would come from the following sources: Smart Growth Stabilization ($234,726.18), Sustainability Account ($400,000.00), remaining funds from the West Street TIP project ($313,944.35) and Downtown Watermain Improvements ($451,329.47). Considering the known funds available the Town expects to allocate and expend $4M for the total project. Furthermore, there is potential to reduce Town expenditures as the Town continues to pursue additional relevant grant opportunities as they present themselves. Below is a breakdown of the funding sources: MassWorks Grant$2,600,000.00 Town Funds$1,400,000.00 Borrowing$0 Total Project Cost$4,000,000.00 The proposed article is requesting Town Meeting to authorize a total project of $4M. This is expected to cover construction cost for High Street (Washington St. to Woburn St.) and Haven Street (Gould St. to High St.) improvements. Finance Committee Report:At their meeting on March X, 2025, the Finance Committee voted X-X to recommend Article 13to Town Meeting. Bylaw Committee Report:No Report. ARTICLE 14To see if the Town will vote to raise and appropriate, borrow, transfer from available funds or otherwise provide a sum or sums of money to pay the costs ofdesigning and otherwise known as the Zanni Parcel located off Symonds Way, including replacement of roadway, sidewalks, and relatedparking and pedestrianimprovementson the abutting parcel on , and further, including the payment of any and all other costs incidental and related thereto,said sum to be expended under the direction of the Town Manager; and, for the purpose of meeting such appropriation, authorize the Town Treasurer, with the approval of the Select Board, to borrow said sum in accordance with G.L. c. 44, §7(1), or any other enabling authority,or take any other action with respect thereto. Select Board Background:TheTown of Reading enjoys a robust Pickleball community. Pickleball is the fastest-growing sport in America, and players come of all ages. Its accessibility is part of its appeal. Currently, the town has four courts at Memorial Park, two converted Tennis Courts, and four sub-par courts by Reading Memorial High School. These courts do not meet the demand we have seen in Reading for years. Utilization rates at our Memorial Park courts are nearly 100% of available playing time, and waiting lists are long. During the Feasibility Study phase of the Reading Center for Active Living project, the architectural firm BH+A identified a portion of the parcel as ideal for pickleball courts. Previously, the Town had planned to build eight new courts during the Birch Meadow Phase 2 project, but due to the high noise level of pickleball, residents and the Town agreed that putting those courts so close to homes was less than ideal. Last fall, the Reading Pickleball Players Association (RPPA) approached the town to see if the pickleball portion of the ReCAL project could be pursued separately. The RPPA had begun . Ideally, the organization wished for a complex with eight lighted courts. The location at Symonds Way is optimal because the residences are within a distance, the constrained site is ideal for courts, and additional supplemental parking is available in the gravel lot behind Burbank Arena. Should the ReCAL project also pass, the whole facility would provide a remarkable complex for indoor and outdoor recreation, wellness, and activity for our 60+ residents and the community at large. The Select Board authorized staff to utilize the remaining ARPA funds in December 2024 to explore the development of Pickleball courts off Symonds Way/Range Road. The town secured the services of the ReCAL architectural firm BH+A, which in turn hired the landscape architecture firm Activitas LLC to work on this project. The Town has worked extensively with Activitas on several projects, including Birch Meadow Phases 1 and 2. The project team received input from the Reading Pickleball Players Association (RPPA) and public safety, conservation, planning, engineering, recreation, and finance. The determination was made to estimate the costs for the design of seven (7) accessible pickleball courts with lights, fencing, post-tension concrete, benches, a shade structure, stormwater retention basins, and some parking. Estimates were refined down to $1,792,000 as of the writing of this report. The project team is optimistic that the project should come in at $1.5M or less, as the $1,792,000 figure includes contingency fees to cover the unpredictable bidding climate developing around building projects. Key design features include: On-site stormwater detentionMany projects we see in other communities that are less expensive are due in part to being able to route stormwater into existing drainage catch basins. Because this project is on undeveloped land, all the stormwater runoffs will have to be retained onsite in underground infiltration chambers, which adds to costs. SiteworkPrior to construction, the town will have to remove trees and stumps, remove and dispose of soils, bring electricity to the site, and much more. This work is more extensive than similar projects in other communities building asphalt courts on flat fields. Post-Tension ConcreteEngineering and Recreation Staff and Design professionals agree that post-tension concrete is the preferred surface for our Pickleball courts, considering the site's geology. Asphalt as a product is not the surface it once was and often leads to cracking and major repairs within just a few years. Considering this land is not an existing, compacted field, the post-tension concrete is preferable and offers a much longer lifespan with an advantageous lifecycle cost. Other communities wespoke with noted that their asphalt courts already required resurfacing within 5-6 years. It is common for post-tension concrete to last 20-30 years, requiring only moderate updates to the playing surface (painting lines, etc.). Furniture Benches and a shade structure are included in the design and cost estimation and are familiar to projects of this size. Funding sources identified other than borrowing for this project include: $200,000 fundraised by the RPPA $100,000 from Recreation Capital Projects for FY26 $200,000 from the Burbank Arena Trust Fund (total available is $400,000). This $500,000 would reduce the town's borrowing costs. Our CFO has $1.6M to borrow for this project. With a projected cost of $1,792,000, the Town would have to borrow $1,292,000. Based on the final cost at bidding, the project scope may be reduced by one court and/or lighting. Finance Committee Report:At their meeting on March X, 2025, the Finance Committee voted X-X to recommend Article 14to Town Meeting. Bylaw Committee Report:No Report. ARTICLE 15To see if the Town will vote to raise and appropriate, borrow, transfer from available funds or otherwise provide a sum or sums of money to pay the costs of lead mitigation improvements towater system, includingthe payment of any and all other costs incidental and related thereto, or take any other action with respect thereto. Select Board Background:In the ongoing efforts to enhance the town's water system, the Town of Reading has initiated a town-wide lead service line replacement program. As requested by the Town of Reading (Town), Weston & Sampson Engineers, Inc. (Weston & Sampson) performed data collection, data review, and GIS mapping services to provide the Town with a summary of its existing water service inventory and potential strategies for lead water service line replacement. Approximately 5% of Town-owned services and 11% of private services are either lead, galvanized iron, or unknown service material. Research has shown that galvanized iron water services, especially when preceded by lead piping or materials such as a lead gooseneck, can be equally as harmful as lead material. Therefore, galvanized water services are recommended for replacement as well as all lead services. In 2024, the Town of Reading completed Phase 1 of its lead removal program. To date the Town has removed approximately 206 lead/galvanized water services with approximately 250 remaining. The Town seeks to continue the program with Phase 2, which will remove an additional 100 services at a cost of $1,500,000. Additionally, in 2024 the Massachusetts Water Resources Authority (MWRA) approved an additional $100 million in 10 year no-interest loan assistance to communities who fully replace lead services. There is a 25% grant component for communities who fully fund the removal of lead services on private property. The purpose of this article is to approve $1,500,000 for Phase 2 of the Town Lead removal Program. Finance Committee Report:At their meeting on March X, 2025, the Finance Committee voted X-X to recommend Article 15 to Town Meeting. Bylaw Committee Report:No Report. ARTICLE 16To see if the Town will vote to amend Section 10.1 of the Zoning Bylaw, the Floodplain Overlay District, including updates to incorporate revised FEMA Flood Insurance Rate Maps (FIRMs) in Section 10.1.2 of the Zoning Bylaw, Regulations, including permit requirements and related definitions,or take any other action with respect thereto. Community Planning and Development Commission Background:In order to remain in compliance with the Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA) updates to the National Flood Insurance Program (NFIP) the Town must amend existing Zoning Bylaw Section 10.1 Floodplain Overlay District to incorporate both Maps (FIRM) establishing in July 2025. By seeking amendments and approval in April the Town will remain in compliance with the effective changes come July so that the Town and property owners are not removed from the NFIP programs or allowances. Proposed bylaw amendments to Section 10.1 include reorganization of existing sub- sections, amendment/addition to existing sub-sections, and the addition of new sub- sections. Finance Committee Report:No Report. Bylaw Committee Report:No Report. ARTICLE 17To see if the Town will vote pursuant to G.L. c. 40, § 15A to transfer a drainage easement located across a certain parcel of land identified on the Town of Reading -0000-0139.0, also known as Parcel B on a plan entitled Consulting Engineers and Land Surveyors, dated September 23, 1999 and recorded with the Middlesex South Registry of Deeds as Plan No. 1071 of 1999 in Book 30698, Page 578, to the Select Board for general municipal purposes, and to authorize the Select Board to partially release, relocate, or amenda Town-owned said drainage easement in a manner acceptable to the Town and in a form acceptable to Town Counsel, and to take such other and further actions or execute such other and further documents as may be necessary to effectuate the purposes of this article, or take any other action with respect thereto. Select Board Background:The Town currently has title and interest in a drainage easement over the property located off Annette Lane, assessors map 38 parcel 139, known as Parcel B on September 23, 1999. The property is under development and the owner is requesting that a portion of the easement be abandoned as it creates a burden on the property. The existing easement was established for the potential extension of Colburn Road, which never was constructed. By eliminating a portion of the easement, the owner can construct a building which is further away from the wetland on site. The owner believes that by relocating the home further away from the wetland it will increase the value of the property and subsequent sale of the home. Since the road was never constructed the Town sees no reason to utilize the full easement in the future. No additional utilities are proposed to occupy this easement in the future. If approved the Town will release all rights, title, and interest to a portion of the easement as depicted in the plan below. Finance Committee Report:No Report. Bylaw Committee Report:No Report. ARTICLE 18To see if the Town will vote, pursuant to Section 2-6 of the Reading Home Rule Charter, to declare the seats of certain Town Meeting Members to be vacant and remove certain described persons from their position as Town Meeting Members for failure to take the oath of office within 30 days following the notice of election or for failure to attend one-half or more of the Town Meeting sessions during the previous year, or take any other action with respect thereto. Select Board Background: Town Meeting Members Attendance 2025 Annual Town Meeting Article 18 Total of 2 Town Meetings resulting in 4 evenings of attendance Listed below are those who attended 1 evening or less Precinct Vote Remove Remain FirstLastPrecinct from Liston List PrecinctMiddleTermTotal NameNameVoteRemain Remove in TMfrom TM 3JohnDBreslin20261 3AmyJames20270 7KerryCrehanDunnell20271 8ChristopherDCosta20261 118 Town Meeting Members had perfect attendance in 2024 Remove from List and Remain in Town Meeting or Remain on the List and be Removed from Town Meeting: Town Meeting Members that have low attendance are added to the list to be removed from Town Meeting. If you vote to leave the name on the list, they are removed from Town Meeting. If you vote to remove the name from the list, they remain a member of Town Meeting. Finance Committee Report:No Report. Bylaw Committee Report:No Report. and you are directed to serve this Warrant by posting an attested copy thereof in at least one (1) public place in each precinct of the Town not less than fourteen (14) days prior to April 28, 2025, or providing in a manner such as electronic submission, holding for pickup or mailing, an attested copy of said Warrant to each Town Meeting Member. Hereof fail not and make due return of this Warrant with your doings thereon to the Town Clerk at or before the time appointed for said meeting. th Given under our hands this __day of ___________, 2025. _______________________ Carlo Bacci _______________________ Mark L. Dockser _______________________ Karen Gately Herrick _______________________ ChristopherHaley _______________________ Melissa Murphy SELECT BOARD OF READING _______________________________ , Constable Town of Reading Meeting Minutes 2016-09-22 LAG Board -Committee -Commission -Council: Finance Committee Date: 2025-03-12Time: 7:00PM Building: Reading Town Hall Location: Select Board Meeting Room Address: 16 Lowell StreetSession: Open Session Purpose: Public HearingVersion: Draft Attendees:Members -Present: Chair Joe Carnahan, Vice Chair Marianne McLaughlin-Downing, Endri Kume, Joe McDonagh, Ed Ross, Emily Sisson, John Sullivan, Mark Zarrow Members -Not Present: Geoffrey Coram Others Present: CFO Sharon Angstrom, Town Manager Matt Kraunelis, Assistant Town Manager Jayne Wellman, Town Clerk Laura Gemme, Community Services Director Jenna Wood (remote), Operations Director Katie Gabriello (remote), Human Resources Director Sean Donahue (remote), Community Development Director Andrew MacNichol (remote), CTO Kevin Furilla, Health Director Ade Solarin, Fire Chief Greg Burns, Assistant Fire Chief Rick Nelson, Police Chief David Clark, DPW Director Chris Cole, Library Director Amy Lannon, Facilities Director Joe Huggins, Assistant Facilities Director Kevin Cabuzzi, Carlo Bacci, Mark Dockser (remote), Chris Haley (remote), Patrick Egan (remote), Karen Rose-Gillis (remote), Nancy D (remote), Christopher Cook (remote), Tony D'Arezzo Minutes Respectfully Submitted By:Jacquelyn LaVerde Topics of Discussion: This meeting was held in-person in the Town Hall Select Board Meeting Room and remotely via Zoom. Chair Joe Carnahan called the meeting to order at 7:02 pm. Roll call attendance: Mark Zarrow (remote), Joe McDonagh, Emily Sisson, Marianne McLaughlin-Downing, Ed Ross, Endri Kume, John Sullivan, Joe Carnahan. The Select Board was called to order at 7:03 pm. Roll call attendance: Mark Dockser (remote), Chris Haley (remote), Carlo Bacci. Liaison Reports No reports. PUBLIC HEARING: Town Manager Recommended Budget for FY26 Marianne McLaughlin-Downing read the Public Hearing Notice. On a motion by Emily Sisson, seconded by Joe McDonagh, the Finance Committee voted 8-0-0 to open the Public Hearing. 24 Page | 1 Roll call vote: Mark Zarrow Yes, Joe McDonagh Yes, Emily Sisson Yes, Marianne McLaughlin-Downing Yes, Ed Ross Yes, Endri Kume Yes, John Sullivan Yes, Joe Carnahan Yes. Chair Carnahan welcomed general public comments. Select Board member Mark Dockser advocated for using some amount of free cash to lower the amount of borrowing the community needs to do for capital projects. Chief Financial Officer Sharon Angstrom provided a detailed overview of the projected revenues, shared costs, and capital and debt.FINCOM approved $5.8 million use of free cash back in the fall, but Ms. Angstrom is proposing to use $6 million due to the 13.6% increase in health insurance costs and other increased costs due to inflation Assistant Town Manager Jayne Wellman presented the Administrative Services and Public Services department budgets for FY26. Administrative Services delivers a level services budget. Ms. Wellman noted a significant reduction in election costs, as there is only one election scheduled in FY26, versus five elections in FY25. Property and Casualty insurance increases 2.5%. In Public Services the part-time Volunteer Coordinator position in the Elder Services Division, which was previously funded by ARPA funds, is now included in the budget. Community Development, Operations, and Human Resources all remain at static staffing levels, with some savings from staffing turnover. The Public Services Department continues to pursue grants to help fund work to support community initiatives. Most of the grants the department currently has are state grants that should not be affected by federal cuts, though the Town is still awaiting payment of the grant money for the Maillet Sommes Morgan project. Chief Technology Officer Kevin Furilla presented the technology department's budget, which shows an 8.1% overall increase, largely due to an additional $54,000 for licensing the town- wide security system, as the licensing the system came with will expire this fall. The budget also includes a $5,000 increase to print services and a decrease in overtime, as there are fewer projects anticipated in FY26. Health Director Ade Solarin reviewed the Health Department proposed budget. There is a $29,900 increase in salaries, which includes a $15,500 increase to the Health Nurse salary, which was previously split between Health and the Elder Human Services Division, but is now fully funded under the Health department. For expenses, there is a $2,000 increase for mosquito control, and a $1,000 decrease to professional development. Fire Chief Greg Burns and Assistant Fire Chief Rick Nelson presented the Fire Department budget for FY26, proposing a 2.7% overall increase. The budget includes a 2.5% increase in salaries and an 8.4% increase in expenses including uniforms, protective equipment, and professional development. The Department is currently down five positions, following four retirements and a transfer. They have already hired one replacement, who will not be in the academy until July. Assistant Chief Nelson highlighted several grants the department has received, including a $93,000 federal grant. The first step of the program is underway right now, for which $10,000 will be expended and reimbursed soon. Most of the program will not happen until October, so if federal funding is canceled, the department will come up with another plan. Police Chief David Clark reviewed the budget for the Police Department, Dispatch, and the Coalition for Prevention and Support. The department is fully staffed, but expects two retirements this spring, and the department has already begun reviewing resumes. The budget requests minor increases for equipment such as radio batteries and cruisers, and a significant increase for new parking enforcement software and devices. Sharon Angstrom presented the Finance Department budget, which sees a 3.0% overall increase. The budget includes a 5.5% increase in wages due to steps and cost of living adjustments for all staff, which is non-union, and a 12.2% decrease in expenses due to a third community contributing to the shared services of the Regional Assessor. 25 Page | 2 DPW Director Chris Cole reviewed the proposed FY26 Department of Public Works budget and enterprise funds. There is no change in staffing numbers, but there are currently a few open positions in Engineering, Highway, and Parks/Cemetery. The overall general fund wages are increasing 4.8% based on contractual and non-union compensation requirements. Overall expenses are decreasing 1.6% due to a $150,000 decrease in Professional Services, as the dead tree removal and invasive plant management in the Town Forest will be done in April of this year. For Enterprise Funds, water wages increase 3.6% based on contractual requirements, and expenses increase 45%, mostly due to a $200,000 increase for the second water meter program. Sewer wages increase 4.7% and operating expenses increase 18% for maintenance costs and supplies. Stormwater wages increase 4.8%, and operating expenses increase 4.7% for drainage, maintenance, equipment, and supplies. Town Manager Matt Kraunelis and CFO Sharon Angstrom briefly reviewed the PEG Cable Access Enterprise Fund, which is decreasing slightly per the contracts with the cable providers, and the Landfill Enterprise Fund, which is the same amount of $37,000 each year for environmental monitoring of the former landfill site, which is now Staples, Home Depot, and Jordans Furniture. Library Director Amy Lannon reviewed the requested Library budget for FY26, which increases overall 3.6%. The library is fully staffed with no increase in FTEs. Wages increase 3.2%. All staff are non-union. Overall expenses increase 5.4%, due to increase in equipment contracts, and software licenses. There was a new line item for $17,000 for Professional Services for outsourced vendors to assist the Office of Equity and Social Justice. It is a net increase of $10,500, as $6,500 was moved from other line items. Facilities Director Joe Huggins reviewed the Core Facilities and Town Facilities budget. The overall increase is 3.4%, with wages increasing 3.6% and expenses increasing 3.3%. There is a 33% increase in the elevator contract, as the old, inexpensive contract expired. A new contract was competitively bid through procurement, and now the department is paying market rate. Pest management increases 28% due to the limited allowable materials, and an uptick in rodents. Energy budgets increase a total of 1.3%. Ms. Angstrom reviewed several adjustments to the Capital Plan. The Finance Committee engaged in a lengthy discussion on the use of free cash, the impact of inflation on the budget, and the potential need for an override. On a motion by Marianne McLaughlin-Downing, seconded by Emily Sisson, the Finance Committee voted 8-0-0 to close the Public Hearing. Roll call vote: Mark Zarrow Yes, Joe McDonagh Yes, Emily Sisson Yes, Marianne McLaughlin-Downing Yes, Ed Ross Yes, Endri Kume Yes, John Sullivan Yes, Joe Carnahan Yes. The Select Board was de facto adjourned, as it is not known when Carlo Bacci and Mark Dockser left the meeting. Future Meetings and Agendas The Finance Committee will be posted to attend the Capital Project Public Forum at the High nd School Performing Arts Center on April 2. th At the next meeting on March 19, the Committee will vote on the FY26 Budget and Annual Town Meeting financial articles. st There is a Special Town Meeting scheduled for May 1, which will consist of warrant articles for the Killam and ReCAL projects. The warrant for the Special Town Meeting will be closed stnd by the Select Board on April 1. The Finance Committee agreed to meet on April 2 at 6:30 pm at the High School just ahead of the Capital Projects Public Forum, to vote on those warrant articles. 26 Page | 3 Approve Prior Meeting Minutes The Committee reviewed the draft minutes from March 5, 2025 and agreed on a minor grammatical correction. On a motion by Emily Sisson, seconded by Marianne McLaughlin-Downing, the Finance Committee voted 8-0-0 to approve the meeting minutes of March 5, 2025 as amended. Roll call vote: Mark Zarrow Yes, Joe McDonagh Yes, Emily Sisson Yes, Marianne McLaughlin-Downing Yes, Ed Ross Yes, Endri Kume Yes, John Sullivan Yes, Joe Carnahan Yes. On a motion by Emily Sisson, seconded by Ed Ross, the Finance Committee voted 8-0-0 to adjourn at 10:32 pm. Roll call vote: Mark Zarrow Yes, Joe McDonagh Yes, Emily Sisson Yes, Marianne McLaughlin-Downing Yes, Ed Ross Yes, Endri Kume Yes, John Sullivan Yes, Joe Carnahan Yes. 27 Page | 4